arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv math/0311103math.GM
收藏

对古德斯坦论点的标准解释有多明确?

How definitive is the standard interpretation of Goodstein's argument?

Bhupinder Singh Anand

摘要:

古德斯坦的论点本质上是,任何给定的自然数m在自然数基b中的遗传表示m_{[b]}可以在康托算术中得到镜像,并用于很好地定义超限序数的有限递减序列,每个超限序数都不小于古德斯坦的自然数序列G(m)的相应成员所对应的序数。这个论点的标准解释是,首先,G(m)因此必须收敛;第二,这个结论-古德斯坦定理-在皮亚诺算术中是不可证明的,但在算术的标准解释下是正确的。然而,我们认为,即使假设古德斯坦的定理确实是不可证明的PA,它的真理,但必须是一个直观的一些建设性的解释古德斯坦的推理无可非议的后果。我们认为这样的解释,并构建一个古德斯坦功能序列,以突出为什么古德斯坦的参数的标准解释不应该被接受为一个明确的属性的自然数。

英文摘要:

Goodstein's argument is essentially that the hereditary representation m_{[b]} of any given natural number m in the natural number base b can be mirrored in Cantor Arithmetic, and used to well-define a finite decreasing sequence of transfinite ordinals, each of which is not smaller than the ordinal corresponding to the corresponding member of Goodstein's sequence of natural numbers G(m). The standard interpretation of this argument is first that G(m) must therefore converge; and second that this conclusion---Goodstein's Theorem---is unprovable in Peano Arithmetic but true under the standard interpretation of the Arithmetic. We argue however that even assuming Goodstein's Theorem is indeed unprovable in PA, its truth must nevertheless be an intuitionistically unobjectionable consequence of some constructive interpretation of Goodstein's reasoning. We consider such an interpretation, and construct a Goodstein functional sequence to highlight why the standard interpretation of Goodstein's argument ought not to be accepted as a definitive property of the natural numbers.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑