设计的再利用:迫切寻求跨学科的认知方法
Reuse of designs: Desperately seeking an interdisciplinary cognitive approach
摘要:
本文分析了“设计的再利用:跨学科的认知方法”研讨会接受的论文。被认为是重要的(作者和/或我们)的几个方面和问题的解决:什么是“跨学科的认知”的作者所采用的方法的性质?设计真的是一个特别适合使用CBR的领域吗?CBR和其他方法之间是否有重要的区别?案例之外的哪些类型的知识正在或可能被用于CBR系统?关于案件:是否存在不同的案件“类型”和不同的案件使用类型?采用何种形式表达?案件是否有“组成部分”?案例在案例记忆中是如何组织的?关于它们的检索:使用哪些类型的索引?检索基于哪种类型的关系?如何仅检索选定数量的病例,即,如何只检索“最佳”病例?系统及其用户使用哪些流程和策略?最后,CBR系统的发展的一些重要方面进行了简短的讨论:CBR系统应该是辅助或自治系统?案例知识如何“获得”?CBR系统的经验评估如何?结论部分指出了研究的不足之处:对使用者的关注不够,采用跨学科认知研究方法的论文少之又少。
英文摘要:
This text analyses the papers accepted for the workshop "Reuse of designs: an interdisciplinary cognitive approach". Several dimensions and questions considered as important (by the authors and/or by us) are addressed: What about the "interdisciplinary cognitive" character of the approaches adopted by the authors? Is design indeed a domain where the use of CBR is particularly suitable? Are there important distinctions between CBR and other approaches? Which types of knowledge -other than cases- is being, or might be, used in CBR systems? With respect to cases: are there different "types" of case and different types of case use? which formats are adopted for their representation? do cases have "components"? how are cases organised in the case memory? Concerning their retrieval: which types of index are used? on which types of relation is retrieval based? how does one retrieve only a selected number of cases, i.e., how does one retrieve only the "best" cases? which processes and strategies are used, by the system and by its user? Finally, some important aspects of CBR system development are shortly discussed: should CBR systems be assistance or autonomous systems? how can case knowledge be "acquired"? what about the empirical evaluation of CBR systems? The conclusion points out some lacking points: not much attention is paid to the user, and few papers have indeed adopted an interdisciplinary cognitive approach.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。