arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv cs/0012013q-fin.GN
收藏

税收与估值

Taxation and Valuation

Leonid A. Levin

AI总结:

本文指出客观评估税基存在根本不可能性,提出对公开交易公司按比例征收可拍卖股票以替代企业所得税和撤资税,从而彻底消除税收对经济激励的扭曲。

摘要:

我解释了消除税收引发的经济激励扭曲的努力持续失败的根源。它在于客观评估税基的根本不可能性。在公开交易的股份公司部门,扭曲可以被完全避免。通过对股票征税(以股票形式,待拍卖)而非现金征税,可以绕过估值问题。股票资本包括成本基础(B)和未实现收益(G)。目前,收益在通过撤资实现之前是递延纳税的。这种递延通过企业所得税(税率 t)来弥补。i 是特殊恒定价值“cv-bonds”的可变利率。拟议的系统将(1)企业所得税替换为对递延 G*t 的利息,并将(2)撤资税替换为对 B*t 的利息。为了征收这两项,IRS 将定期把私人持有的公开交易股票的一小部分 i*t 拿去拍卖。注意:(2)是一种中性简化:投资可以拆分为 B(1-t) 的股票和 B*t 的债券投资组合。债券利息买回被拍卖的股票,免税撤资与原始收益率相匹配。i*t 的股票税与等值 cv-bonds 投资组合的所得税相匹配。财政部也可以将其收入(通过债券销售)与对整个股票市场回报的税率 t 税收相匹配(而不会诱使价格操纵)。它可以改变 i 以将债券发行量保持在市值的 t 比例;此时股票拍卖提供债券利息。纳税人也可以单方面通过将资本中的 t 比例保留为债券来匹配此类税收负担。主要特征是:公司和投资者的任何行为都无法改变其税收(股票的 i*t 比例),因此商业决策将与无税时完全相同。对股息和资本利得的税收将不再阻碍资本流动,公司将摆脱令人困惑的税法、法规和先例的迷宫;国会仍将征收与目前相同的收入。

英文摘要:

I explain the root of persistent failure of efforts to remove tax-induced distortions of economic incentives. It lies in FUNDAMENTAL IMPOSSIBILITY of objectively evaluating tax base. Distortions can be entirely avoided in the sector of publicly traded corporations. Evaluation can be bypassed by taxing it in shares (to be auctioned) rather than cash. Stock capital includes cost basis (B) and unrealized gains (G). Gains are presently tax-deferred until realized in divestment. The deferral is remedied by corporate income tax (rate t). i is the variable interest rate on special constant value "cv-bonds". The proposed system replaces (1) corporate income tax - with interest on the deferred G*t, and (2) divestment taxes - with interest on B*t. To collect both, IRS will periodically take to auction a fraction i*t of privately held publicly traded shares. Note: (2) is a neutral simplification: Investments can be split into B(1-t) stock and B*t in bond portfolios. Bond interest buys back the auctioned shares, and tax-free divestment matches the original yield. The i*t stock tax matches the income tax on cv-bond portfolios of equal value. The Treasury, too, could match its income (in bond sales) to the rate t tax on the full stock market return (without tempting price manipulation). It can vary i to keep the bond volume at a fraction t of market capitalization; then share auctions supply bond interest. Taxpayers, too, could unilaterally match their burden to such tax by keeping a fraction t of capital in bonds. The main feature is: nothing companies and investors do can change their tax (fraction i*t of shares), so business decisions would be exactly the same as without taxes. No longer would taxes on dividends and capital gains impede capital flow, companies would forget bewildering mazes of tax laws, regulations, precedents; Congress would still collect the same revenue it now does.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑