量子与经典机器学习在神经精神疾病中的应用:特征匹配的多队列评估
Quantum Versus Classical Machine Learning for Neuropsychiatric Disorders: A Feature-Matched Multi-Cohort Evaluation
AI总结:
本研究在四个神经精神疾病队列中,通过特征匹配对比六类量子与经典机器学习模型,发现多数量子模型与经典模型表现相当,无一致更优的量子模型,还分析了量子-经典对等的原因。
摘要:
静息态功能连接被广泛用于基于机器学习的神经精神疾病分类。已有研究提出将量子机器学习模型应用于功能连接数据,但很少有研究在留站点验证或与匹配的经典模型对比的场景下对其进行评估。本研究在四个公共队列(共4308名受试者)中,使用相同的相关衍生特征,将六类量子模型与经典模型进行对比。对自闭症脑成像数据交换(ABIDE I)、ADHD-200(注意缺陷/多动障碍)和REST-meta-MDD(重度抑郁症)队列采用留站点验证,对加州大学洛杉矶分校神经精神表型联盟(UCLA-CNP)队列采用分层10折交叉验证。在所有四个队列中,量子核与匹配的经典核在统计学上无显著差异,95%置信区间下的平均准确率差异在1.4个百分点以内。在ABIDE I队列中,混合量子卷积网络的准确率与其经典对应模型相近(0.645 vs. 0.641),而可训练量子核的曲线下面积(AUC)比其经典对应模型高出0.064。量子卷积网络在该队列的AUC也高于其匹配的经典网络,且在所有四个队列中表现出更小的训练-测试差距,但未获得准确率提升。总体而言,大多数量子模型与经典模型表现相当,但没有任何量子模型始终优于经典模型。本研究是首批在留站点验证下对ABIDE I进行量子评估的研究之一,提供了包含284项匹配对比的量子与经典模型的特征匹配基准。我们进一步分析了基于保真度的图构建,并通过有效维度和本征谱分析解释了观察到的量子-经典对等现象。
英文摘要:
Resting-state functional connectivity is widely used in machine learning-based classification of neuropsychiatric disorders. Quantum machine learning models have been proposed for functional connectivity data, but few studies have evaluated them under leave-site-out validation or against matched classical models. We compared six quantum model families with classical ones using identical correlation-derived features across four public cohorts (4,308 subjects). Leave-site-out validation was used for the Autism Brain Imaging Data Exchange (ABIDE I), ADHD-200 (attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder), and REST-meta-MDD (major depressive disorder) cohorts, while the UCLA Consortium for Neuropsychiatric Phenomics (UCLA-CNP) was evaluated using stratified 10-fold cross-validation. The quantum kernel was statistically indistinguishable from a matched classical kernel across all four cohorts, with the average accuracy difference within 1.4 percentage points at 95% confidence. On ABIDE I, a hybrid quantum convolutional network achieved similar accuracy to its classical counterpart (0.645 vs. 0.641), while a trainable quantum kernel exceeded its classical counterpart by 0.064 in area under the curve (AUC). Quantum convolutional networks also achieved higher AUC than their matched classical networks on this cohort and showed smaller train-test gaps on all four cohorts, without an accuracy gain. Overall, most quantum models matched their classical counterparts, but none consistently outperformed them. This study, among the first quantum evaluations of ABIDE I under leave-site-out validation, provides a feature-matched benchmark of quantum and classical models comprising 284 matched comparisons. We further analyse fidelity-based graph construction and account for the observed quantum-classical parity through effective-dimension and eigenspectrum analyses.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。