arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2610.21160cs.RO
收藏

何时求助:双系统视觉-语言-动作模型中慢模块调度的决策理论解释与测量标准

When to Ask for Help: A Decision-Theoretic Account and Measurement Standard for Slow-Module Scheduling in Dual-System Vision-Language-Action Models

North China University of Technology(北方工业大学)

Shilin Zhang

AI总结:

该研究针对双系统VLA模型的慢模块调度问题,提出基于干预价值的决策理论框架,通过实验验证了调度规律,将慢模块调用从设计意见转化为可测量决策。

摘要:

双系统视觉-语言-动作(VLA)模型将高频快速策略与慢速、高开销模块配对,已发表的调用机制缺乏共同目标、可测量的开销,以及任何能将调度质量与模块质量区分开的标准。我们提供了缺失的解释:调用被形式化为一个校准的决策问题,其固定比例、固定预算和历史门控调度是同一量——干预价值(VoI)的退化情况;一个更新基线证明,在状态独立崩溃下最优调度是周期性的,自适应增益由开销比ρ和崩溃的离散度决定。测量的系统在ρ上跨越三个数量级(FiS-VLA为0.95;RoboICL约为10³),直接测试证实了低ρ预测:在同质崩溃下校准增益消失,且随异质性增长。在LIBERO上的14个闭环臂测试了连续体的争议中间(ρ=1.53):自适应触发器的查询分配完全符合阈值规则预测,但语言重写通道无法将其转化为任一套件的成功,而撤销失败重写的恢复执行器是唯一在LIBERO-Spatial和LIBERO-Goal上净下行风险为零的干预,其中重写缺陷从13点加深至42点。一个四指标无泄漏协议在929条部署轨迹上将表观预警AUC从0.93降至0.62,一个检测受限前沿定理将检测质量转化为可调度性陈述,一个编译循环将测量的价值函数转化为每任务刷新周期,与闭环神谕的偏差在2.4%以内。这些结果共同将慢模块调用从设计意见转变为可测量的决策。

英文摘要:

Dual-system vision-language-action (VLA) models pair a high-frequency fast policy with a slow, expensive module, and published trigger mechanisms for invoking it lack a shared objective, measured costs, and any standard separating schedule quality from module quality. We provide the missing account: invocation is formalized as a calibrated decision problem whose fixed-ratio, fixed-budget, and history-gated schedules are degenerate cases of one quantity, the Value of Intervention (VoI); a renewal baseline proves the optimal schedule periodic under state-independent collapse, with adaptive gains governed by the cost ratio $ρ$ and the dispersion of collapse. Measured systems span three orders of magnitude in $ρ$ (FiS-VLA $0.95$; RoboICL about $10^3$), and a direct test confirms the low-$ρ$ prediction: calibrated gains vanish under homogeneous collapse and grow with heterogeneity. Fourteen closed-loop arms on LIBERO test the contested middle of the continuum ($ρ=1.53$): the adaptive trigger allocates its queries exactly as the threshold rule predicts, yet the language-rewrite channel cannot convert them into success on either suite, and a revert actuator that undoes a failed rewrite is the only intervention with zero net downside on both LIBERO-Spatial and LIBERO-Goal, where the rewrite deficit deepens from thirteen to forty-two points. A four-measure leak-free protocol cuts apparent early-warning AUC from $0.93$ to $0.62$ on $929$ deployment traces, a detection-limited frontier theorem converts detection quality into a schedulability statement, and a compilation loop turns measured value functions into per-task refresh periods within $2.4\%$ of the closed-loop oracle. Together these results turn slow-module invocation from a design opinion into a measured decision.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑