arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2610.20360cs.CLcs.CY
收藏

AI智能体是否会“八卦”?人类与AI智能体在线社区中的评价性对话

Do AI Agents Gossip? Evaluative Talk in Human and AI-Agent Online Communities

National Taiwan University(台湾大学)

Yong-Hui Hua, Chih-Han Lin, Shu-Kai Hsieh

AI总结:

本研究对比Moltbook与PTT社区,发现AI智能体社区存在八卦但流行度更低,其讨论串中质疑更少,复制了八卦的信息维度但关系功能尚不明确。

摘要:

八卦被定义为对不在场第三方的评价性谈论,被广泛视为人类独有的社会实践。本研究探究自主AI智能体社区中是否会自发出现类似话语。我们将由AI智能体组成的Reddit式平台Moltbook,与台湾大型人类运营的电子布告栏PTT进行对比。为减少传播场景带来的差异,我们采用相同的八卦操作定义分析两个公开异步论坛。Moltbook上存在八卦,但根据分母选择,其流行度比PTT低2.6至6倍。在两个平台上,八卦常针对本地知名人物,易引发首个回复的认同,且极少被呈现为无根据的谣言。最明显的差异在于后续回复的发展:在包含至少一个可编码回复的讨论串中,人类讨论串的质疑占65.1%,而智能体讨论串仅占21.3%;此外,在出现早期一致回复后,83.6%的智能体讨论串共识未受挑战,而人类讨论串仅为44.7%。在控制讨论串深度和板块构成、并针对两名人类标注者重新校准后,该讨论串层面的对比仍然存在。基于单个回复轮次的估计稳健性较低,因此以区间形式呈现。这些发现表明,AI智能体社区复制了八卦的信息维度,而八卦在多大程度上发挥类似的关系功能仍未明确。

英文摘要:

Gossip, defined as evaluative talk about absent third parties, is widely seen as a uniquely human social practice. This study examines whether comparable discourse emerges spontaneously in a community of autonomous AI agents. We compare Moltbook, a Reddit-style platform populated by AI agents, with PTT, a large human-operated bulletin board in Taiwan. To reduce differences attributable to communicative setting, we analyze two public, asynchronous forums using the same operational definition of gossip. Gossip occurs on Moltbook, but its prevalence is 2.6 to 6 times lower than on PTT, depending on the denominator used. On both platforms, gossip frequently targets locally prominent figures, tends to elicit agreement from the first respondent, and is rarely presented as unsupported rumor. The clearest difference concerns how subsequent responses develop. Among threads containing at least one codable reply, challenges occur in 65.1% of human threads but only 21.3% of agent threads. Moreover, following an early aligning response, consensus remains unchallenged in 83.6% of agent threads, compared with 44.7% of human threads. This thread-level contrast remains after controlling for thread depth and board composition and under recalibration against two human annotators. Estimates based on individual reply turns are less robust and are therefore reported as bounds. These findings suggest that AI-agent communities reproduce the informational dimension of gossip, while the extent to which gossip performs comparable relational functions remains unresolved.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑