哪些文本重要:处理文本作为数据回归中的模型不确定性,并应用于央行沟通
Which Text Matters: Handling Model Uncertainty in Text-as-Data Regressions, with an Application to Central Bank Communication
AI总结:
该研究针对文本作为数据回归中的模型不确定性问题,提出SSGAMs模型,以欧洲央行新闻发布会文本为研究对象,筛选出跟踪专业通胀预期的稀疏文本指标,发现常用替代指标及非线性效应无增量信息。
摘要:
社会科学家通常将文本转换为主题份额、理想点或情感得分等协变量,并将其纳入感兴趣的统计模型中。这种两步设计很方便,但很少有理论指导:几乎没有理论告诉分析者应构建或纳入哪些基于文本的协变量。每种方法都包含有争议的测量选择,同一构念的不同操作化方式可能支持不同的结论,因此单个研究问题会产生一系列相互竞争的回归模型。因此,哪些文本构建的协变量应纳入模型以及采用何种函数形式,是一个模型不确定性问题。我们提出了尖峰-平板广义加性模型(SSGAMs),该模型可联合选择协变量并确定其效应是线性还是非线性。我们以一个强大的非选举产生机构的沟通为例,询问2002年末至2025年中期224次欧洲央行月度新闻发布会的45个相互竞争的文本指标中,哪些能跟踪专业通胀预期。结果选择了一组稀疏的指标;广泛使用的替代指标以及所有测试的非线性效应均无增量信息。
英文摘要:
Social scientists routinely convert text into covariates like topic shares, ideal points or sentiment scores, and insert them into statistical models of interest. This two-step design is convenient, but it is rarely guided by theory: little tells the analyst which text-based covariates to construct or include. Each approach embodies contestable measurement choices, and competing operationalizations of the same construct can support different conclusions, so a single research question gives rise to a menu of competing regression models. Which text constructed covariates belong in a model, and in what functional form, is thus a problem of model uncertainty. We propose spike-and-slab generalized additive models (SSGAMs), which jointly select covariates and determine whether their effects are linear or nonlinear. We illustrate the approach with the communication of a powerful unelected institution, asking which of 45 competing text indicators from 224 monthly European Central Bank press conferences, spanning late 2002 to mid-2025, track professional inflation expectations. A sparse set is selected; widely used alternatives, and every tested nonlinear effect, carry no incremental information.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。