一种用于人工智能辅助鉴别诊断的面向安全的假设-演绎框架
A safety-oriented hypothetico-deductive framework for AI-assisted differential diagnosis
AI总结:
研究针对诊断错误威胁,提出AegisDx框架,通过协调LLM组件进行鉴别诊断、筛查危险情况、验证推理等。经多层面评估,该框架在诊断准确率及安全评分等方面表现优于独立LLM,为急性护理提供更优床边决策支持
摘要:
诊断错误对患者安全构成重大威胁,当前大型语言模型(LLM)系统常将诊断视为一次性预测任务,缺乏对遗漏高风险替代方案的防范或对其推理的严格验证。本文提出了AegisDx,一个面向安全的假设-演绎临床推理框架。AegisDx通过特定角色的契约、结构化中间输出、证据检索接口和验证门来协调专门的LLM组件,以生成广泛的鉴别诊断,对危险的“绝不能漏诊”情况进行明确筛查,根据可靠的医学证据验证推理,并构建可操作的下一步措施。我们在三个层面评估了AegisDx。在来自《新英格兰医学杂志》(NEJM)和《美国医学会杂志》(JAMA)的文献衍生病例报告上,以GPT-oss-120B为共享主干,AegisDx在JAMA病例上的前3名诊断准确率为59.9%,而独立LLM为52.1%;在NEJM病例上分别为62.7%和51.4%。在《急诊医学年鉴》的病例上,前3名准确率为85.7%,而独立LLM为68.6%;在与医生共识的绝不能漏诊诊断集对比中,AegisDx在78.0%的病例中前3名诊断中捕获了至少一种此类情况,而独立LLM为52.0%。在对耶鲁纽黑文医疗系统43份真实世界急诊科记录与GPT-5进行的盲法医生评估中,AegisDx将医生评定的综合安全评分从4.31提高到4.55(5分制,调整后p = 2.1x10^-4),在绝不能漏诊识别和推理安全性方面有定性提升。我们的研究结果表明,将诊断人工智能设计为面向安全的推理框架,而非仅优化原始预测准确率,可为急性护理工作流程提供更安全、更透明且具有临床意义的床边决策支持层。
英文摘要:
Diagnostic error is a major threat to patient safety, yet current large language model (LLM) systems often treat diagnosis as a one-shot prediction task, lacking safeguards against missed high-risk alternatives or rigorous verification of their reasoning. Here, we present AegisDx, a safety-oriented framework for hypothetico-deductive clinical reasoning. AegisDx coordinates specialized LLM components through role-specific contracts, structured intermediate outputs, evidence-retrieval interfaces, and verification gates to generate broad differential diagnoses, enforce explicit screening for dangerous "must-not-miss" conditions, verify reasoning against grounded medical evidence, and structure actionable next steps. We evaluated AegisDx across three layers. On literature-derived case reports from NEJM and JAMA, with GPT-oss-120B as the shared backbone, Top-3 diagnostic accuracy was 59.9% versus 52.1% for the standalone LLM on JAMA cases and 62.7% versus 51.4% on NEJM cases. On cases from Annals of Emergency Medicine, Top-3 accuracy was 85.7% versus 68.6%; against physician-consensus must-not-miss diagnosis sets, AegisDx captured at least one such condition among its top three diagnoses in 78.0% of cases versus 52.0%. In a blinded physician evaluation of 43 real-world emergency department notes from the Yale New Haven Health System compared against GPT-5, AegisDx improved the physician-rated composite safety score from 4.31 to 4.55 on a 5-point scale (adjusted p = 2.1x10^-4), with qualitative gains in must-not-miss identification and reasoning safety. Our findings suggest that engineering diagnostic AI as a safety-oriented reasoning framework, rather than optimizing raw predictive accuracy alone, can provide a safer, more transparent, and clinically meaningful layer of bedside decision support for acute care workflows.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。