arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2607.04838cs.CY
收藏

法律裁决中争议内容的心理特征与公众对人工智能的接受度:超越个体差异的系统变异证据

Psychological features of dispute content and public acceptance of AI in legal adjudication: evidence for systematic variation beyond individual differences

Kansai University(关西大学)

Masahiro Fujita, Eiichiro Watamura

AI总结:

研究通过对日本参与者的两项研究,探究争议内容的心理特征对算法裁决可接受性判断的影响,揭示了争议类型结构及情境特征对其的调制作用,表明争议内容心理特征是人工智能接受研究中被忽视的维度。

摘要:

公众对人工智能在法律决策中的接受度主要通过人格特质和一般技术态度的个体差异来解释。然而,法律纠纷本身的情境特征可能会系统地影响对人工智能与人类裁决者的偏好。通过两项针对日本参与者的研究,我们考察了纠纷内容的心理特征是否会影响算法裁决的可接受性判断。研究1对46个法律纠纷 vignettes 的可接受性评级进行了探索性因素分析,揭示了一个二维结构,将人际纠纷(强烈倾向于人类裁决者)与制度程序纠纷(人工智能接受度相对较高)区分开来。研究2在独立样本中复制了这一结构,并表明实验操纵的情境特征——情感卷入和典型性——系统地调节了可接受性判断,其效果因性格信任、特定于人工智能的态度和性别而异。特定于人工智能的期望成为最强的预测因素(eta2 = 0.252),情感卷入、性别和典型性之间的三向交互表明情境效应受到个体特征的调节。这些发现表明,纠纷内容的心理特征构成了人工智能接受研究中一个被忽视的维度,超越了技术接受模型,延伸到关于个体如何理解社会问题和分配裁决权的基本问题。

英文摘要:

Public acceptance of artificial intelligence (AI) in legal decision-making has been primarily explained through individual differences in personality traits and general technology attitudes. However, contextual features of legal disputes themselves may systematically influence preferences for AI versus human adjudicators. Across two studies with Japanese participants (N = 1,384 and N = 596), we examined whether psychological characteristics of dispute content shape acceptability judgments for algorithmic adjudication. Study 1 employed exploratory factor analysis on acceptability ratings across 46 legal dispute vignettes, revealing a two-dimensional structure distinguishing interpersonal-relational disputes (where human adjudicators were strongly preferred) from institutional-procedural disputes (where AI acceptance was comparatively higher). Study 2 replicated this structure in an independent sample and demonstrated that experimentally manipulated contextual features - emotional involvement and prototypicality - systematically modulated acceptability judgments, with effects varying by dispositional trust, AI-specific attitudes, and gender. AI-specific expectations emerged as the strongest predictor (eta2 = 0.252), and a three-way interaction among emotional involvement, gender, and prototypicality indicated that contextual effects are moderated by individual characteristics. These findings suggest that the psychological features of dispute content constitute an overlooked dimension in AI acceptance research, extending beyond technology acceptance models to fundamental questions about how individuals construe social problems and allocate adjudicative authority.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑