arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2607.04503cs.CY
收藏

美国福利管理中的混合算法治理:以州和县级人工智能为例的支持-控制趋同

Hybrid Algorithmic Governance in U.S. Welfare Administration: State- and County-Level AI as a Case of Support-Control Convergence

National Research University Higher School of Economics(国立高等经济大学)

Maxim Dedyaev

AI总结:

探讨美国福利管理中人工智能系统作为支持或控制工具的运行条件,基于支持-控制趋同概念等,通过六个案例过程追踪发现系统方向受制度设计影响,控制易发生,转向支持难且代价大。

摘要:

本文研究美国福利管理中人工智能系统作为支持或控制工具运行的制度条件。从支持和控制在同一系统中共存且相对平衡随时间变化的前提出发,通过支持-控制趋同概念和制度棘轮模型进行概念化。通过六个州和县级案例的过程追踪得出相关发现。

英文摘要:

This article examines the institutional conditions under which artificial intelligence systems in U.S. welfare administration come to operate as instruments of support or as instruments of control. Rather than asking what welfare algorithms "really" are (tools of proactive assistance or infrastructures of surveillance) the article starts from the premise that support and control are co-present within the same system, while their relative balance shifts over time. This movement is conceptualized through the notion of support-control convergence and the model of an institutional ratchet. Routine budgetary and political pressures make control-oriented effects easily measurable and politically capitalizable, whereas a return toward support requires external intervention of disproportionate force, such as judicial compulsion, legislative prohibition, or public scandal. Empirically, the article draws on process tracing of six state- and county-level cases: NYSDOL fraud detection, Michigan MiDAS, Illinois Medicaid managed care, LA County homelessness prevention, the Allegheny Family Screening Tool, and Washington Foster Care. The findings show that the system's orientation is shaped by institutional design, with the decisive parameter being the side on which the costs of algorithmic error are placed. Drift toward control is routine, while reversal is exceptional and costly. In the MiDAS case, activation required a single administrative decision, whereas reversal took nine years and a $20 million settlement; even then, the system did not return to a support-oriented configuration.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑