用户体验设计师的静态、滚动讲述和聊天机器人可视化入门技术比较研究
A Comparative Study of Static, Scrollytelling, and Chatbot Visualization Onboarding Techniques for UX Designers
AI总结:
针对用户体验设计师创建数据可视化时面临的问题,通过实验研究评估静态、滚动讲述和聊天机器人三种可视化入门技术,测量相关指标并调查偏好体验,探讨设计维度及启示。
摘要:
用户体验(UX)设计师在创建数据可视化时面临障碍,因为可视化领域专业知识有限或不熟悉专业工具。这凸显了对有效培养可视化素养方法的明确需求。为解决此问题,我们在一项有25名UX设计师和学生的实验研究中评估了三种可视化入门技术——静态、滚动讲述和聊天机器人。我们在可视化创建任务期间测量了可视化理解和指南遵守情况,随后进行了调查和访谈以获取偏好和体验。与静态入门相比,汇总的交互条件(滚动讲述或聊天机器人)在可视化创建期间与显著更高的指南遵守分数相关;两种交互技术也获得了更高的参与度评分。当汇总两个交互条件时,指令清晰度评分显著更高。不同条件下的理解没有显著差异。虽然参与者普遍更喜欢交互技术,但在性能或入门体验评分方面,滚动讲述和聊天机器人之间没有出现显著差异。基于这些发现,我们讨论了可视化入门的三个设计维度(叙事结构、视觉内容布局和导航灵活性)、它们的设计含义以及该领域未来研究的潜在机会。
英文摘要:
User experience (UX) designers face barriers when creating data visualizations due to limited domain expertise in visualization or unfamiliarity with specialized tools. This highlights a clear need for effective methods to build visualization literacy. To address this, we evaluated three visualization onboarding techniques -- static, scrollytelling, and chatbot -- in an experimental study with 25 UX designers and students. We measured visualization comprehension and guideline adherence during a visualization creation task, followed by surveys and interviews to capture preferences and experiences. Compared to static onboarding, the pooled interactive condition (scrollytelling or chatbot) was associated with significantly higher guideline-adherence scores during visualization creation; both interactive techniques also received higher engagement ratings. Instruction clarity ratings were significantly higher when the two interactive conditions were pooled. Comprehension did not differ significantly across conditions. While participants generally preferred the interactive techniques, no significant differences emerged between scrollytelling and chatbot in performance or onboarding experience ratings. Drawing on the findings, we discuss three design dimensions of visualization onboarding (narrative structure, visual content layout, and navigational flexibility), their design implications, and potential opportunities for future research in this field.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。