科学界女性面临的倾斜竞争环境
The Tilted Playing Field for Women in Science
AI总结:
本研究通过分析650万作者近500万篇论文,发现机构声望对科研产出的回报存在性别差异:女性仅在顶尖机构获得与男性相当的声望优势,而男性在更广泛的机构层级中持续受益,且差距随成就水平扩大。
摘要:
机构声望影响着科学资源的获取、可见性和合作机会。然而,声望是否平等地惠及研究者,以及它如何与科研生产力和合作差异相关,仍不清楚。在这里,我们将声望优势量化为:与较低排名机构的同行相比,较高排名机构的研究者拥有更多合作者并产出更多高影响力论文的相对可能性。通过分析来自超过65,000个机构的650万作者发表的近500万篇论文,我们提出了一个分布式的、尾部敏感的框架来比较不同群体间的声望优势。我们发现,声望与科学成就之间的关联因性别而系统性地不同。虽然男性和女性都从声望中受益,但回报并非性别中立的:女性仅在顶尖机构体验到可比的优势,而男性在更广泛的机构层级中保持持续优势,且差距在更高成就水平上扩大。声望优势也呈非线性增长,不成比例地惠及最精英机构的作者。这些差异与合作模式一致:女性的网络更倾向于本地聚类并集中于自身机构,而男性则更广泛地跨机构层级合作。这些发现共同揭示了科学界一个倾斜的竞争环境:声望不均等地放大成功,而网络结构决定了谁能获得其利益。
英文摘要:
Institutional prestige shapes access to resources, visibility, and collaboration opportunities in science. Yet whether prestige benefits researchers equally, and how it relates to differences in scientific productivity and collaboration, remains unclear. Here, we quantify prestige advantage as the relative likelihood that researchers at higher-ranked institutions have more collaborators and produce more high-impact papers compared to their lower-ranked peers. Analyzing nearly 5 million papers by 6.5 million authors across more than 65,000 institutions, we present a distributional, tail-sensitive framework to compare prestige advantage across groups. We find that the association between prestige and scientific achievement differs systematically by gender. While both men and women benefit from prestige, the returns are not gender-neutral: women experience comparable advantages only at the most elite institutions, whereas men retain persistent advantages across the broader hierarchy, with disparities widening at higher levels of achievement. Prestige advantage also grows nonlinearly, disproportionately benefiting authors at the most elite institutions. These differences align with collaboration patterns: women's networks are more locally clustered and focused on their own institution, while men collaborate more broadly across institutional strata. Together, these findings reveal a tilted playing field in science: one where prestige amplifies success unevenly and network structure shapes who can access its benefits.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。