arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2605.23922cs.CYcs.AIcs.LG
收藏

高风险人工智能系统与欧洲人工智能法案中的身份问题

High-Risk AI Systems and the Problem of Identity in the European AI Act

Institute of Biomedical Ethics and History of Medicine, University of Zürich(伦理与医学史研究所,苏黎世大学);SUPSI, Dalle Molle Institute for Artificial Intelligence (IDSIA)(SUPSI,达勒莫利人工智能研究所);ETH Zürich(苏黎世联邦理工学院)

Andrea Ferrario

AI总结:

本文通过功能+框架分析欧盟AI法案中高风险AI系统的身份认定问题,提出同步身份测试方法以支持监管审计。

摘要:

欧盟人工智能法案(AIA)为高风险AI系统建立了一个生命周期治理制度,围绕事前合规评估、上市后监测以及在“重大修改”时重新评估。这些义务预设了AI身份判断:监管机构和提供者必须决定更新后的系统是否随时间保持同一系统。在这项工作中,我们展示了如何通过人工制品身份的功能+框架来澄清这一逻辑,该框架通过预期功能以及适当功能的上下文相关标准(即“AI可信度”)来个体化AI系统。我们进一步论证,AIA没有为同步身份提供内部、可审计的标准——即在给定时间两个AI系统在监管目的上是否应被视为相同——而是基本上将这种相同性判断委托给部门或协调工具。功能+提供了一个以预期功能和可信度概况及水平为基础的同步身份测试,使得同步身份决策在采购、责任和市场监督等治理环境中可检查。我们的贡献是一个概念性和审计视角:我们提供了AIA生命周期义务与功能+身份组件之间的对应图,并通过一个用于审计和争议情境的最小决策流程使同步案例在操作上清晰可读。最后,我们提出两个面向实施的建议:(1)更精确、可测试的预期用途报告,以及(2)标准化、可审计的可信度报告,支持跨时间和跨部署的可比性。

英文摘要:

The EU Artificial Intelligence Act (AIA) establishes a lifecycle governance regime for high-risk AI systems built around ex-ante conformity assessment, post-market monitoring, and re-assessment upon "substantial modification." These obligations presuppose AI identity judgments: regulators and providers must decide when an updated system remains the same system over time. In this work, we show how this logic is clarified by the function+ framework of artifact identity, which individuates AI systems by their intended function together with context-sensitive criteria of appropriate functioning, captured as "AI trustworthiness." We further argue that the AIA does not provide an internal, auditable criterion for synchronic identity--when two AI systems at a given time should count as the same for regulatory purposes--and instead largely defers such sameness determinations to sectoral or harmonization instruments. function+ supplies a synchronic identity test anchored in intended function and trustworthiness profiles and levels, making synchronic identity decisions inspectable in governance settings such as procurement, liability, and market surveillance. Our contribution is a conceptual and auditing lens: we provide a correspondence map between AIA lifecycle obligations and function+ identity components, and we make the synchronic case operationally legible via a minimal decision flow for audit and dispute contexts. We conclude with two implementation-facing recommendations: (1) more precise, testable reporting of intended purpose, and (2) standardized, auditable trustworthiness reporting that supports comparability over time and across deployments.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑