arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2605.23917cs.CL
收藏

用于自动科学假设生成的多角色辩论系统

Multi-Persona Debate System for Automated Scientific Hypothesis Generation

Department of Materials Science & Engineering, Ajou University(材料科学与工程系,阿乔大学);Department of Energy Systems Research, Ajou University(能源系统研究系,阿乔大学);Department of Nuclear Science and Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology(核科学与工程系,麻省理工学院);Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology(材料科学与工程系,麻省理工学院);Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology(材料科学与工程系,乌山国家科学与技术研究院);Graduate School of Artificial Intelligence, Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology(人工智能研究生院,乌山国家科学与技术研究院)

Jaeha Oh, Byungchan Kim, Ju Li, Yang Jeong Park, Jin-Sung Park

AI总结:

提出多角色辩论系统(MPDS),结合文献检索、长上下文大语言模型推理、语料驱动角色归纳和结构化多智能体辩论,自动生成科学假设,在电池材料研究中验证其有效性。

摘要:

现代科学发现的瓶颈不在于数据稀缺,而在于无法将碎片化知识综合为可操作的假设。这一挑战在电池材料研究中尤为突出,因为电化学性能、界面行为和制造可行性必须同时优化。在此,我们提出多角色辩论系统(MPDS),这是一个基于文献的自动科学假设生成框架,结合了文献检索、长上下文大语言模型推理、语料驱动角色归纳和结构化多智能体辩论。MPDS构建最多500篇论文的文献快照,将智能体基于角色特定的证据池,并进行三轮引文感知辩论,随后由主持人综合,从而在保持证据可追溯性的同时实现角色间的协商。我们使用时间控制协议评估MPDS,排除对目标论文的直接访问,包括两个留出的电池材料案例研究和30个匹配案例的盲比较。在钠离子阳极和全固态电池阴极设计任务中,MPDS恢复了与实验验证解空间一致的设计逻辑,并生成了比简单基线更机械明确、过程感知的提案。为了评估角色和辩论的影响,我们引入了综合假设质量评分。在消融研究中,MPDS在五种条件下获得了最高平均分,其最大优势在于跨视角整合。实验室后续表明其作为识别工作流程中实际瓶颈的诊断辅助工具的实用性。这些结果表明,在耦合工程约束下,对文献快照的结构化辩论改善了假设形成,并为文本密集型科学发现提供了可重用工作流程。

英文摘要:

Modern scientific discovery is bottlenecked not by data scarcity, but by the inability to synthesize fragmented knowledge into actionable hypotheses. This challenge is especially acute in battery materials research, where electrochemical performance, interfacial behavior, and manufacturing feasibility must be optimized simultaneously. Here, we present the Multi-Persona Debate System (MPDS), a literature-grounded framework for automated scientific hypothesis generation that combines literature retrieval, long-context large language model reasoning, corpus-driven persona induction, and structured multi-agent debate. MPDS constructs literature snapshots of up to 500 papers, grounds agents in role-specific evidence pools, and conducts a three-round citation-aware debate followed by moderator synthesis, enabling negotiation between personas while preserving evidence traceability. We evaluate MPDS using a temporally controlled protocol excluding direct access to target papers, including two held-out battery-materials case studies and a blinded comparison across 30 matched cases. In sodium-ion anode and all-solid-state battery cathode design tasks, MPDS recovered design logics aligned with experimentally validated solution spaces and generated more mechanistically explicit, process-aware proposals than simpler baselines. To assess the impact of personas and debate, we introduce Integrative Hypothesis Quality scoring. In ablation studies, MPDS achieved the highest mean score among five conditions, with its largest advantage in cross-perspective integration. A laboratory follow-up suggests utility as a diagnostic aid for identifying practical bottlenecks in workflows. These results indicate that structured debate over literature snapshots improves hypothesis formation under coupled engineering constraints and provides a reusable workflow for text-intensive scientific discovery.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑