有和无手机通知抑制的学生编程行为
Student programming behavior with and without phone notification suppression
AI总结:
本研究探讨了手机通知抑制对学生编程任务参与度和生产力的影响,发现抑制通知能提高注意力和专注时间,但效果在学生间存在显著差异。
摘要:
背景与情境。计算机编程通常涉及长时间的持续活动,而手机通知会频繁打断。先前研究表明抑制通知可减少这些中断。目标。我们的主要研究问题是:抑制通知如何影响学生编程时的任务参与度和生产力?方法。我们报告了一项在CS1课程中进行的复制和方法学扩展研究,涉及22名学生。采用被试内设计,选定的编程作业被随机分配为启用通知抑制或不启用。通过毫秒级分辨率的IDE键盘敲击数据与手机状态日志同步,以测量学生在控制条件和通知抑制条件下的注意力和专注度。发现。在启用通知抑制的作业中,许多但并非所有学生表现出更低的休息率和更长的专注间隔。本研究提供了通知抑制与编程参与和行为可测量差异相关的证据。我们还发现学生间的效果存在显著双峰分布——许多学生受益,少数学生受损,极少数学生无明显影响。这一发现与其他学科研究一致。意义。我们的结果表明,对于许多学生而言,通知抑制工具(如勿扰模式)可以提高注意力和专注度。这些结果适用于教育环境(勿扰模式作为干预)和学术研究(理解手机干扰的影响)。
英文摘要:
Background and Context. Computer programming often involves extended periods of sustained activity and mobile phone notifications introduce frequent opportunities for interruption. Prior work demonstrates that suppressing phone notifications may reduce these disruptions. Objectives. Our primary research question is: How does suppressing phone notifications affect students' task engagement and productivity while programming? Method. We report on a replication and methodological extension study conducted in a CS1 course involving 22 students. Using a within-subject design, selected programming assignments were randomly designated for enabling notification suppression. Phone state logs were synchronized with millisecond-resolution IDE keystroke data to measure student attention and focus when in the control and notification-suppression conditions. Findings. Assignments completed with notification suppression enabled significantly lower break rates and longer intervals of focus compared to assignments completed in the control condition for many, but not all, students. This study provides evidence that notification suppression is associated with measurable differences in programming engagement and behavior. We also find a remarkable bimodality in the effect across students -- many students are positively affected, a small number are negatively affected, and very few experience little or no effect. This finding is consistent with other studies in diverse disciplines. Implications. Our results show that, for many students, phone notification suppression tools, such as Do Not Disturb, can improve attention and focus. Implications apply to educational settings (do-not-disturb as an intervention) and scholarship (understanding the effects of phone distraction).
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。