脑数据对机器学习有多大价值?
How Much is Brain Data Worth for Machine Learning?
AI总结:
本文通过数学建模探讨脑数据与任务数据在机器学习中的价值与交换率,分析不同条件下脑数据对模型性能的提升作用。
摘要:
如果一个人能够完成某项任务,通过测量其大脑活动是否能更容易地训练模型完成相同任务?最近的神经AI研究表明,结合神经记录的任务训练可以适度提高模型性能和鲁棒性。然而,不清楚何时使用神经数据会有好处,以及预期的收益有多大。我们通过数学公式提出这个问题,并使用一个简单、可分析的线性高斯模型来理论性地开始解决它。对于同时训练于脑数据和任务标签的多模态估计器,我们推导出性能随脑数据和任务样本数量的缩放定律。从这些定律中,我们推导出脑样本与任务样本之间的相对价值和交换率,量化了神经数据相对于任务数据的价值,取决于任务-脑对齐、神经和任务噪声、潜在维度以及脑数据样本数量。我们还分析了测试分布偏移,以确定在哪些条件下通过学习不变性可以产生显著的鲁棒性提升。最后,在固定的收集预算下,我们表征了脑数据值得收集的条件。我们的结果为理解脑数据如何有助于改进机器学习提供了基础。
英文摘要:
If a person can solve a task, can measuring their brain make it easier to train a model to solve that task too? Recent NeuroAI work suggests that supplementing task training with neural recordings can modestly improve model performance and robustness. However, it is unclear when there should be a benefit from using neural data and how much benefit to expect. We formulate this question mathematically, and begin to address it theoretically using a simple, analytically tractable linear gaussian model of task targets and neural recordings. For a multimodal estimator trained on both brain data and task labels, we derive scaling laws for how performance scales with the numbers of brain and task samples. From these laws we derive relative value and exchange rates between brain samples and task samples, quantifying how much extra task samples neural data is worth as a function of task-brain alignment, neural and task noise, latent dimension, and brain data sample size. We also analyze test distribution shift, to identify conditions where brain-regularized learning can produce substantial robustness gains through learned invariances. Finally, under a fixed collection budget, we characterize the regimes in which brain data is worth collecting. Our results provide a foundation for understanding how valuable brain data could be for improving machine learning.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。