arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2605.08486cs.CY
收藏

教师对AI在教育中的感知益处与风险:对LLM对齐与可控性的审计

Teachers' Perceived Benefits and Risks of AI Across Fifty-Five Countries: An Audit of LLM Alignment and Steerability

Cornell University(康奈尔大学);KTH Royal Institute of Technology(皇家理工学院);Linköping University(林雪平大学)

Yan Tao, Olga Viberg, Deepak Varuvel Dennison, Zhikun Wu, René F. Kizilcec

AI总结:

研究通过分析55国教师对AI的感知益处与风险,评估LLM在教育领域应用的对齐与可控性,揭示模型输出与现实差异,警示LLM不能替代教师直接反馈。

摘要:

教师对人工智能在教育中的信任取决于他们如何平衡其感知的益处和风险。然而,全球关于扩大AI在教育中的讨论依赖于碎片化的证据,因为大多数研究集中在单一国家或小样本上。这种缺乏代表性跨国家证据限制了理论构建和政策发展。同时,大型语言模型(LLM)越来越多地用于研究、政策和教师专业流程中,尽管在教育领域验证有限。为解决这些差距,我们通过结合代表性国际调查数据和系统模型评估,进行大规模审计,评估LLM与教师对AI感知的对齐程度。使用OECD TALIS数据从55个国家和领土中,我们测量跨国家教师对AI感知益处和风险的差异。然后,我们通过四种提供者下的八个最先进的LLM在一般和国家特定提示下进行基准测试,比较高和低推理模型。结果揭示了教师感知中显著的跨国家差异,这些差异在LLM输出中并不可靠地反映。模型压缩国家差异,高估了益处和风险,并且从身份提示或增强推理中获得有限的改进。这种不匹配很重要,因为LLM生成的指导和专业话语越来越多地塑造教师如何学习和讨论AI,可能影响信任和未来采用决策。我们的发现警告不要将LLM输出视为替代教师直接反馈来指导全球AI在教育中的倡议。同时,某些模型(例如Gemini 3 Fast)部分捕捉了跨国家排名模式,表明在假设生成和探索性比较分析中有互补作用。

英文摘要:

Teachers' trust in artificial intelligence (AI) in education depends on how they balance its perceived benefits and risks. Yet global discussions about scaling AI in education rely on fragmented evidence, as most studies of teachers' perceptions focus on single countries or small samples. This lack of representative cross-national evidence limits both theory building and policy development. At the same time, large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used in research, policy, and teachers' professional workflows, despite limited validation in education. To address these gaps, we conduct a large-scale audit of LLM alignment with teachers' perceptions of AI by combining representative international survey data with systematic model evaluation. Using OECD TALIS data from 55 countries and territories, we measure cross-national variation in teachers' perceived benefits and risks of AI. We then benchmark responses from eight state-of-the-art LLMs across four providers under both general and country-specific prompting, comparing higher- and lower-reasoning models. Results reveal substantial cross-national variation in teacher perceptions that is not reliably reflected in LLM outputs. Models compress country differences, overestimate both benefits and risks, and show limited gains from identity prompting or enhanced reasoning. This misalignment matters because LLM-generated guidance and professional discourse increasingly shape how teachers learn about and discuss AI, potentially influencing trust and future adoption decisions. Our findings caution against treating LLM outputs as substitutes for direct engagement with teachers when informing global AI-in-education initiatives. At the same time, some models (e.g., Gemini 3 Fast) partially capture cross-national ranking patterns, suggesting a complementary role in hypothesis generation and exploratory comparative analysis.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑