在心理空间中绘制线条:K均值聚类在模拟和真实心理测量数据中揭示的内容
Drawing Lines in Psychological Space: What K-means Clustering Reveals in Simulated and Real Psychometric Data
AI总结:
本文探讨了K均值聚类在模拟和真实心理测量数据中的局限性,通过对比分析指出其在连续高斯潜在空间中仍能产生稳定且视觉一致的聚类结果。
摘要:
K均值聚类在心理和心理测量研究中广泛用于识别个人资料、子群体和潜在类型,但其经典公式并未检验这些群体是否作为潜在的心理类别存在。相反,K均值将多维空间划分为围绕质心的区域,倾向于由几何距离定义的紧凑、近似球形的聚类。本文通过一系列受控的模拟数据集检验这一限制,然后扩展分析到SMARVUS数据集,一个包含来自35个国家大学学生的大型国际心理测量数据集,以评估在经验心理数据中是否会出现类似的几何划分模式。通过对比模拟和经验数据,本文论证K均值即使在没有真实子群体结构的连续高斯潜在空间中,也能产生稳定且视觉一致的聚类解决方案。
英文摘要:
K-means clustering is widely used in psychological and psychometric research to identify profiles, subgroups, and potential typologies, yet its classical formulation does not test whether such groups exist as latent psychological categories. Instead, K-means partitions multidimensional space into regions around centroids, favoring compact, approximately spherical clusters defined by geometric distance. In this paper, we examine this limitation through a sequence of controlled simulated datasets. We then extend the analysis to the SMARVUS dataset, a large international psychometric dataset comprising survey responses from university students across 35 countries, to evaluate whether similar geometric partitioning patterns emerge in empirical psychological data. By contrasting simulated and empirical data, this paper argues that K-means can produce stable and visually coherent clustering solutions even in continuous Gaussian latent spaces without true subgroup structure.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。