arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2604.24147econ.GNcs.CYcs.GTq-fin.ECq-fin.TR
收藏

价格作为焦点:预测市场、条件反射性与共同知识的政治

Price as Focal Point: Prediction Markets,Conditional Reflexivity, and the Politics of Common Knowledge

Devnull FZCO

Maksym Nechepurenko

AI总结:

本文探讨预测市场作为协调机制的功能,通过2024年美国大选数据,提出信号可信度指数评估价格变动的影响力,揭示表面相似事件在精英协调中的不同影响。

摘要:

预测市场常被视为揭示集体对未来不确定性的预测工具。本文论证在特定条件下,它们也充当协调机制:公开概率组织选民、捐赠者、记者、交易者和机构的行为,可能自我实现或自我毁灭。现有研究关注预测准确性,本文则质疑准确预测是否应是市场评估标准。基于2024年美国总统选举的交易级证据,显示市场信号的社会影响力更多取决于持续性、响应交易类型广度及跨平台共识。引入信号可信度指数(SCI),结合方差比VR(6)、双侧诊断及交易者集中度调整,作为预测价格变动行为牵引力的微观结构标准。应用于三大2024年政治冲击事件,框架揭示表面相似事件产生不同信号类型,对精英协调有不同影响。跨平台比较显示社会权威与知识稳健性系统脱钩:最显眼的市场产生最不准确的预测。该框架对监管预测市场作为民主信息基础设施具有直接意义。

英文摘要:

Prediction markets are widely treated as forecasting devices that reveal collective expectations about uncertain futures. This article argues that under specifiable conditions they also function as coordination mechanisms: public probabilities that organize the behavior of voters, donors, journalists, traders, and institutions in ways that can be self-fulfilling or self-defeating. Most existing work asks whether prediction markets forecast accurately; this paper asks whether accurate forecasting is even the right criterion for a market that has become a public coordination device. Drawing on transaction-level evidence from the 2024 U.S. presidential election, we show that the social force of a market signal depends less on its size than on its persistence, the breadth of responding trader types, and cross-platform consensus. We introduce a Signal Credibility Index (SCI) -- combining the variance ratio VR(6), a two-sidedness diagnostic, and a trader-concentration adjustment -- as a microstructure-grounded criterion for predicting when price moves acquire behavioral traction. Applied to three major 2024 political shocks, the framework reveals that superficially similar events generated qualitatively distinct signal types with different implications for elite coordination. A cross-platform comparison establishes a systematic decoupling of social authority from epistemic robustness: the most visible market produced the least accurate forecasts. The framework carries direct implications for regulating prediction markets as democratic information infrastructure.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑