arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2604.23866stat.ME
收藏

对序列多重分配随机试验(SMARTs)中缺失数据的方法和实践的综述:一项关于综述的辅助研究

A Review of Methods and Practices for Missing Data in Sequential Multiple Assignment Randomized Trials (SMARTs): An Ancillary Study of a Scoping Review

Duke University(杜克大学);University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill(北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校)

Nikki L. B. Freeman, Chenyao Yu, Margaret Hoch, Sydney Browder, Bradley G. Hammill, Avi Kenny, Kevin J. Anstrom, Michael R. Kosorok

AI总结:

本文综述了SMARTs中缺失数据的统计方法,并总结了已发表SMARTs中缺失数据的报告和处理方式,指出现有方法与实际应用之间存在显著差距。

摘要:

背景:缺失数据对序列多重分配随机试验(SMART)分析构成严重威胁,因为其具有序列治疗结构和响应依赖性再随机化特性。目标:本研究旨在(1)回顾当前处理SMARTs中缺失数据的统计方法,(2)描述已发表SMARTs中缺失数据的报告和处理方式。方法:我们进行了关于处理SMARTs中缺失数据的统计方法的综述。此外,我们还对之前发表的关于SMARTs的综述进行了预指定的二次提取,重点是缺失数据。提取涵盖了流失率、处理缺失性的方法以及计划与实际的缺失数据分析。结果:确定了七篇方法学论文;几乎所有都假设缺失于随机(MAR),仅有一篇处理了完整的SMART特定缺失类型。在30篇已发表的SMARTs中,总体流失率中位数为18.1%(范围0.6%-56.5%)。处理缺失数据的方法在80%的论文中被描述;混合模型方法最常见(30%)。在14项配对协议研究中,2项(14%)预指定了敏感性分析。结论:SMART特定的缺失数据方法有限,现有方法与当前SMART实践之间存在显著差距。

英文摘要:

Background: Missing data poses an acute threat to sequential multiple assignment randomized trial (SMART) analyses because of the sequential treatment structure and response-dependent re-randomization. Objectives: This study aimed to (1) review the current statistical methods for handling missing data in SMARTs, and (2) characterize how missing data is reported and handled in published SMARTs. Methods: We conducted a narrative review of statistical methods developed for missing data in SMARTs. Additionally, we conducted a pre-specified secondary extraction of a previously published scoping review of SMARTs focused on missing data. Extraction captured attrition rates, methods for handling missingness, and planned versus performed missing data analyses. Results: Seven methodological papers were identified; nearly all assume missing at random (MAR), and only one addresses the full set of SMART-specific missingness types. Across 30 published SMARTs, median overall attrition was 18.1% (range 0.6%-56.5%). Methods used to address missing data were described in 80% of the manuscripts; mixed-model methods were most common (30%). Among 14 studies with paired protocols, sensitivity analyses were pre-specified in 2 (14%). Conclusions: SMART-specific methodology for missing data is limited, and a substantial gap exists between available methodology and current SMART practice.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑