arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2604.23730cs.AI
收藏

对日本律师考试写作任务中LLM开放式法律推理的专家评估

Expert Evaluation of LLM's Open-Ended Legal Reasoning on the Japanese Bar Exam Writing Task

Tohoku University(东大);Tokyo Metropolitan University(东京 Metropolitan 大学)

Jungmin Choi, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Hiroaki Yamada

AI总结:

本文首次提出评估LLM在日本法律领域开放式法律推理能力的数据集,通过法律专家对模型输出的评估揭示了法律推理的局限性与挑战。

摘要:

大型语言模型(LLM)在法律基准测试中表现出色,包括法律考试的多项选择部分。然而,其在现实场景中生成开放式法律推理的能力仍缺乏充分研究。本文首次提出一个数据集,用于评估LLM在日本司法辖区内的开放式法律推理表现。该数据集基于日本律师考试的写作部分,要求考生从长篇叙述中识别多个法律问题,并以自由文本格式构建结构化法律论点。我们的主要贡献是通过法律专家对LLM生成响应的 Manual 评估,揭示了法律推理的局限性和挑战。此外,我们还对幻觉进行了手动分析,以确定模型何时以及如何引入未被先例或法律支持的内容。我们的真实考试问题、模型生成的响应和专家评估揭示了当前LLM在日本法律领域的发展里程碑。我们的数据集和相关资源将在线上提供。

英文摘要:

Large language models (LLMs) have shown strong performance on legal benchmarks, including multiple-choice components of bar exams. However, their capacity for generating open-ended legal reasoning in realistic scenarios remains insufficiently explored. Notably, to our best knowledge, there are no prior studies or datasets addressing this issue in the Japanese context. This study presents the first dataset designed to evaluate the open-ended legal reasoning performance of LLMs within the Japanese jurisdiction. The dataset is based on the writing component of the Japanese bar examination, which requires examinees to identify multiple legal issues from long narratives and to construct structured legal arguments in free text format. Our key contribution is the manual evaluation of LLMs' generated responses by legal experts, which reveals limitations and challenges in legal reasoning. Moreover, we conducted a manual analysis of hallucinations to characterize when and how the models introduce content not supported by precedent or law. Our real exam questions, model-generated responses, and expert evaluations reveal the milestones of current LLMs in the Japanese legal domain. Our dataset and relevant resources will be available online.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑