arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2604.23645econ.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

购买监控权:AI辅助同行评审中的编辑设计

Buying the Right to Monitor:Editorial Design in AI-Assisted Peer Review

University of Luxembourg(卢森堡大学)

Zaruhi Hakobyan

AI总结:

研究探讨AI对同行评审系统的影响,发现当AI能力达到临界点时,评审努力崩溃,导致作者受益但编辑受损。提出编辑应调整录取标准以应对AI带来的挑战。

摘要:

生成式AI作为颠覆性技术冲击进入评估组织。在学术同行评审中,它同时影响买卖双方:作者用AI润色投稿,评审者用它生成合理报告而不付出评估努力。本文开发了一个三方均衡模型分析这种双重采用,并得出一个反直觉的管理启示。我们证明当AI能力超过临界阈值时,评审努力会突然崩溃。这种转变造成福利错配:作者受益于减弱的“竞赛”,而编辑却面临信号信息度下降。通过刻画编辑的最优受限反应,我们识别出严格的政策反转。在AI转变前,编辑应收紧录取标准以遏制作者润色的租金消耗。在转变后,传统直觉失效:编辑必须放宽录取标准并投资AI检测,因为进一步收紧只会加剧消耗性润色而不改善排序。我们证明这种符号反转是log-concave质量分布下评审努力崩溃的结构性结果。最终,应对AI在评估系统中的挑战需要将监控和放宽选择性视为互补的设计工具。

英文摘要:

Generative AI acts as a disruptive technological shock to evaluative organizations. In academic peer review, it enters both sides of the market: authors use AI to polish submissions, and reviewers use it to generate plausible reports without exerting evaluative effort. We develop a three-sided equilibrium model to analyze this dual adoption and derive a counterintuitive managerial implication for journal policy. We show that when AI capability crosses a critical threshold, reviewer effort collapses discontinuously. This transition creates a welfare misalignment: authors benefit from a weakened ``rat race,'' while editors suffer from degraded signal informativeness. Characterizing the editor's optimal constrained response, we identify a strict policy reversal. Before the AI transition, editors should tighten acceptance standards to curb rent-dissipating author polishing. After the transition, conventional intuition fails: editors must loosen acceptance standards while investing in AI detection, because further tightening only amplifies dissipative polishing without improving sorting. We prove analytically that this sign reversal is a structural consequence of the reviewer effort collapse under log-concave quality distributions. Ultimately, addressing AI in evaluative systems requires treating monitoring and loosened selectivity as complementary design instruments.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑