arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2604.09996cs.CV

现代目标检测器在果园图像中稳健苹果检测的比较研究

A Comparative Study of Modern Object Detectors for Robust Apple Detection in Orchard Imagery

Affiliation omitted for double-blind review

Mohammed Asad, Ajai Kumar Gautam, Priyanshu Dhiman, Rishi Raj Prajapati

AI总结:

本文比较了六个现代目标检测器在苹果检测中的性能,发现YOLO11n在严格定位性能上表现最佳,同时分析了不同检测器在阈值鲁棒性和下游任务需求上的差异。

摘要:

准确的苹果检测在果园图像中对于预测产量、水果计数、机器人采摘和作物监测至关重要。然而,变化的照明、树叶杂波、密集的水果簇和部分遮挡使得检测变得困难。为了提供公平且可重复的比较,本研究在公开的AppleBBCH81数据集上建立了单类苹果检测的受控基准,使用确定性的训练、验证和测试划分以及六个代表性检测器的统一评估协议:YOLOv10n、YOLO11n、RT-DETR-L、Faster R-CNN(ResNet50-FPN)、FCOS(ResNet50-FPN)和SSDLite320(MobileNetV3-Large)。主要使用COCO风格的mAP@0.5和mAP@0.5:0.95进行评估,并通过精确-召回曲线和固定阈值的精确度、召回率和F1分数(IoU=0.5)进一步分析阈值依赖行为。在验证划分中,YOLO11n在严格定位性能上表现最佳,mAP@0.5:0.95=0.6065和mAP@0.5=0.9620,随后是RT-DETR-L和YOLOv10n。在固定操作点(置信度>=0.05)下,YOLOv10n获得最高的F1分数,而RT-DETR-L由于许多低置信度的假阳性,获得很高的召回率但低精度。这些发现表明,果园部署中的检测器选择应不仅由定位感知的准确性指导,还应考虑阈值鲁棒性和下游任务的需求。

英文摘要:

Accurate apple detection in orchard images is important for yield prediction, fruit counting, robotic harvesting, and crop monitoring. However, changing illumination, leaf clutter, dense fruit clusters, and partial occlusion make detection difficult. To provide a fair and reproducible comparison, this study establishes a controlled benchmark for single-class apple detection on the public AppleBBCH81 dataset using one deterministic train, validation, and test split and a unified evaluation protocol across six representative detectors: YOLOv10n, YOLO11n, RT-DETR-L, Faster R-CNN (ResNet50-FPN), FCOS (ResNet50-FPN), and SSDLite320 (MobileNetV3-Large). Performance is evaluated primarily using COCO-style mAP@0.5 and mAP@0.5:0.95, and threshold-dependent behavior is further analyzed using precision-recall curves and fixed-threshold precision, recall, and F1-score at IoU = 0.5. On the validation split, YOLO11n achieves the best strict localization performance with mAP@0.5:0.95 = 0.6065 and mAP@0.5 = 0.9620, followed closely by RT-DETR-L and YOLOv10n. At a fixed operating point with confidence >= 0.05, YOLOv10n attains the highest F1-score, whereas RT-DETR-L achieves very high recall but low precision because of many false positives at low confidence. These findings show that detector selection for orchard deployment should be guided not only by localization-aware accuracy but also by threshold robustness and the requirements of the downstream task.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑