arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2604.06178cs.HC
收藏

帮助我,但不要跟踪我:过程感知AI辅导系统的干预时机与隐私边界

"Help Me, But Don't Track Me": Intervention Timing and Privacy Boundaries for Process-Aware AI Tutors

University of California, San Diego(加州大学圣地亚哥分校);Tsinghua University(清华大学)

Jane Hanqi Li, Yuhong Zhang, Jiaqi Liu, Tzyy-Ping Jung, Amy Eguchi

AI总结:

研究探讨了过程感知AI辅导系统中干预时机与隐私边界的设计平衡,发现学生更倾向于自主支持、渐进式帮助和明确的隐私界限。

摘要:

随着生成式AI工具被越来越多地用作数学学习的非正式辅导,未来的系统可能在决定何时和如何提供支持时变得更加主动和过程感知。然而,这种支持引发了重要的设计矛盾:及时的帮助可能会让人感到打扰或过度监控。为了指导过程感知AI辅导系统的设计,我们对中国330名中学生(7-11年级)进行了调查,了解他们偏好的辅导行为、对主动干预的态度以及对学习过程数据的可接受使用。我们发现三个设计相关模式。首先,学生更喜欢保留自主性的支持,如提示而非直接答案。其次,他们更倾向于渐进式的主动支持而非持续打扰,更喜欢先提供小提示,只有在需要时才提供更强的帮助。第三,他们在学习过程数据上划定了清晰的隐私界限:学生对问题解决步骤和错误模式感到舒适,但对注意力或行为相关信号则不太舒适。这些发现为设计平衡及时支持与学习者自主权,以及个性化与感知隐私界限的K-12情境中的AI辅导系统提供了早期实证指导。

英文摘要:

As generative AI (GenAI) tools are increasingly used as informal tutors for mathematics learning, future systems may become more proactive and process-aware in deciding when and how to offer support. Yet such support raises an important design tension: help that is timely may also feel interruptive or overly monitoring. To inform the design of process-aware AI tutors, we surveyed 330 secondary school students in China (Grades 7--11) about their preferred tutoring behaviors, attitudes toward proactive intervention, and acceptable use of learning-process data. We found three design-relevant patterns. First, students preferred autonomy-preserving support, such as hints over direct answers. Second, they favored graduated proactive support over constant interruption, preferring small hints first and stronger assistance only as needed. Third, they drew clear privacy boundaries around learning-process data: students were comfortable with problem-solving steps and mistake patterns, but substantially less comfortable with attention- or behavior-related signals. Together, these findings offer early empirical guidance for designing AI tutors that balance timely support with learner agency, and personalization with perceived privacy boundaries in K-12 contexts.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑