arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2604.03501cs.HCcs.AI
收藏

增强陷阱:人工智能生产力与认知卸载的成本

The Augmentation Trap: AI Productivity and the Cost of Cognitive Offloading

Michael Caosun, Sinan Aral

AI总结:

本文研究了人工智能工具对工人生产力的影响,发现尽管短期生产力提升,但持续使用会侵蚀工人技能。通过动态模型分析,发现即使预期技能损耗,理性决策者仍可能在短期收益大于长期成本时采用AI,导致稳态损失。此外,当管理者短视或工人技能具有外部价值时,决策者可能陷入增强陷阱,使工人状况恶化。最后,当AI生产力与工人技能关联较弱时,工人技能可能永久分化,经验丰富的工人实现潜力,而经验不足的工人技能降至零。

摘要:

实验证据证实,AI工具提高了工人的生产力,但持续使用也会侵蚀支撑这些收益的专业技能。我们开发了一个动态模型,其中决策者在时间上选择工人使用AI的强度,权衡即时生产力与工人技能的损耗。我们将工具的生产力效应分解为两个渠道,一个与工人技能无关,另一个随技能变化。模型产生了三个主要结果。第一,即使决策者完全预见技能损耗,理性决策者在短期生产力收益超过长期技能成本时仍会采用AI,产生稳态损失:工人最终比采用AI前更不 productive。第二,当管理者短视或工人技能具有外部价值时,决策者的最优政策将稳态损失转化为增强陷阱,使工人状况比未采用AI时更差。第三,当AI生产力较少依赖工人技能时,工人技能可以永久分化:经验丰富的工人实现全部潜力,而经验较少的工人技能降至零。小的管理激励差异决定了工人的路径。生产力分解将部署分为五个制度,区分有益和有害的采用,并识别哪些部署容易陷入陷阱。

英文摘要:

Experimental evidence suggests that AI tools raise worker productivity, but also that sustained offloading can erode expertise. This creates a tradeoff when expertise is a complement to AI. To explore the consequences of this tradeoff, we develop a dynamic model in which a decision-maker chooses the intensity of practice-displacing AI offloading for a worker over time, trading immediate productivity against the erosion of worker skill. We decompose the tool's productivity effect into two components, one independent of worker expertise and one that scales with it. The model produces three main results. First, a decision-maker who fully anticipates skill erosion still rationally adopts AI when front-loaded gains outweigh long-run skill costs, lowering long-run productivity. The decomposition sorts deployments into five regions by their long-run effect, separating beneficial from harmful adoption. Second, the tradeoff introduces the potential for misaligned incentives to harm workers. When managers are short-termist or worker skill has external value, AI use can leave the worker worse off than with no AI, the outcome we call the augmentation trap. Third, when AI substitutes strongly enough for expertise, offloading can generate permanent divergence, with high-skill workers realizing their potential and low-skill workers deskilling. Small differences in managerial incentives can determine which path a worker takes.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑