科学出版物、领域和国家间的撤稿流行病
The Retraction Epidemic in Science Across Publishers, Fields, and Countries
AI总结:
研究通过流行病学框架分析撤稿率,发现其呈指数增长,但绝对值仍低,揭示撤稿集中于少数国家的矛盾现象,提出基于发病率的监测方法以保障科研诚信。
摘要:
撤稿是科研诚信失败的指标,但大多数分析关注绝对数量而非每篇论文的风险。我们使用最大的开放文献数据库开发发病率指标,按人口标准化计算:每年每篇论文和活跃作者的撤稿率。应用流行病学框架,我们发现撤稿发病率呈指数增长,论文和作者层面的翻倍时间约为5年。这些模式在领域、出版商和国家间差异显著。尽管全球科学产出日益民主化,撤稿集中于少数国家,形成
英文摘要:
Retractions serve as an indicator of failures in research integrity, yet most analyses focus on absolute counts rather than risk per paper. We use one of the largest open bibliographic databases to develop incidence metrics normalized by population: retractions per publication and per active author annually. Applying an epidemiological framework that models counts with exposure, we find evidence of exponential growth in retraction incidence, with approximately a 5-year doubling time at both the paper and author levels. These patterns vary significantly across fields, publishers, and countries. While scientific output is becoming more democratized globally, retractions are concentrated in fewer countries, creating a "concentration" paradox that calls for targeted monitoring. Despite exponential growth, the absolute incidence remains low (0.12% in 2021), allowing for corrective intervention. Incidence-based monitoring provides a framework for evaluating policies that safeguard research integrity at scale.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。