arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2603.29545cs.CYcs.CR
收藏

独立复杂或维伯犯罪?探索生成AI工具、编码助手和代理在网络犯罪生态系统中的采用与创新

Stand-Alone Complex or Vibercrime? Exploring the adoption and innovation of GenAI tools, coding assistants, and agents within cybercrime ecosystems

University of Cambridge(剑桥大学);University of Edinburgh(爱丁堡大学);University of Strathclyde, Glasgow(斯特拉斯克莱德大学)

Jack Hughes, Ben Collier, Daniel R. Thomas

AI总结:

本文通过创新理论和演化经济学分析网络犯罪生态系统,提出独立复杂和维伯犯罪概念,发现AI在现有低利润方案中有早期应用,但未造成广泛破坏。

摘要:

与生成式人工智能相关的存在性风险场景往往涉及高级系统或代理模型失控并利用黑客工具控制关键基础设施。本文认为生成式AI对网络犯罪的真实威胁不同。我们应用创新理论和演化经济学,将网络犯罪视为小型和中型技术初创企业的生态系统,提出两个新术语界定破坏的上下限。在高端,我们提出独立复杂,即网络犯罪-盒中犯罪解决方案使个体行动者能够大规模自动化现有网络犯罪即服务安排。在低端,我们建议维伯犯罪现象,即“ vibe 编码”降低入门门槛,但不根本改变网络犯罪的经济结构。我们分析了网络犯罪地下早期实证数据,发现现实较为平淡——AI在现有大规模、低利润被动收入方案和微小欺诈中有早期应用,但目前尚无广泛破坏的证据。这取代了现有代码粘贴、错误检查和 cheatsheet 咨询等方法,用于网络犯罪中涉及的软件开发通用方面,并且对于已经熟练的行动者,低技能行动者在维伯编码工具中发现的实用性不如现成的脚本。此外,jailbroken LLMs(暗AI)作为导师的作用也被夸大,鉴于亚文化和社会学习在入门中的重要性——新用户重视学习黑客和网络犯罪技能过程中涉及的社会联系和社区身份,如同知识本身。我们的初步结果表明,即使悲叹维伯犯罪的兴起,也可能夸大当前的破坏程度。

英文摘要:

Existential risk scenarios relating to Generative Artificial Intelligence often involve advanced systems or agentic models breaking loose and using hacking tools to gain control over critical infrastructure. In this paper, we argue that the real threats posed by generative AI for cybercrime are rather different. We apply innovation theory and evolutionary economics - treating cybercrime as an ecosystem of small- and medium-scale tech start-ups, coining two novel terms that bound the upper and lower cases for disruption. At the high end, we propose the Stand-Alone Complex, in which cybercrime-gang-in-a-box solutions enable individual actors to largely automate existing cybercrime-as-a-service arrangements. At the low end, we suggest the phenomenon of Vibercrime, in which 'vibe coding' lowers the barrier to entry, but do not fundamentally reshape the economic structures of cybercrime. We analyse early empirical data from the cybercrime underground, and find the reality is prosaic - AI has some early adoption in existing large-scale, low-profit passive income schemes and trivial forms of fraud but there is little evidence so far on widespread disruption in cybercrime. This replaces existing means of code pasting, error checking, and cheatsheet consultation, for generic aspects of software development involved in cybercrime - and largely for already skilled actors, with low-skill actors finding little utility in vibe coding tools compared to pre-made scripts. The role of jailbroken LLMs (Dark AI) as instructors is also overstated, given the prominence of subculture and social learning in initiation - new users value the social connections and community identity involved in learning hacking and cybercrime skills as much as the knowledge itself. Our initial results, therefore, suggest that even bemoaning the rise of the Vibercriminal may be overstating the level of disruption to date.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑