分析德国议会辩论中的发言秩序请求
Analysing Calls to Order in German Parliamentary Debates
AI总结:
本文研究德国议会辩论中发言秩序请求的出现原因及影响因素,提出基于规则的方法检测并标注此类请求,并构建了包含72年议会辩论数据的新型数据集。
摘要:
议会辩论是政治权力的重要领域,影响立法结果和公众讨论。本文系统研究了德国议会中发言秩序请求(CtO)作为规范违规的正式指标。我们提出了一种基于规则的方法来检测和标注议会演讲中的CtO,并构建了一个包含72年德国议会辩论的新型数据集,其中包括标注的CtO实例。此外,我们开发了首个CtO触发分类系统,并分析了其发生因素。研究发现,尽管有正式规定,CtO的发布在一定程度上是主观的,受会议主席和议会动态影响,某些人受到不成比例的负面影响。对个人的侮辱是最常见的CtO原因。总体而言,男性成员和反对党成员比女性和联合政党成员收到更多CtO。大多数CtO触发器出现在涉及政府事务和总统行为的演讲中。CtO触发器数据集可在https://github.com/kalawinka/cto_analysis获取。
英文摘要:
Parliamentary debate constitutes a central arena of political power, shaping legislative outcomes and public discourse. Incivility within this arena signals political polarization and institutional conflict. This study presents a systematic investigation of incivility in the German Bundestag by examining calls to order (CtO; plural: CtOs) as formal indicators of norm violations. Despite their relevance, CtOs have received little systematic attention in parliamentary research. We introduce a rule-based method for detecting and annotating CtOs in parliamentary speeches and present a novel dataset of German parliamentary debates spanning 72 years that includes annotated CtO instances. Additionally, we develop the first classification system for CtO triggers and analyze the factors associated with their occurrence. Our findings show that, despite formal regulations, the issuance of CtOs is partly subjective and influenced by session presidents and parliamentary dynamics, with certain individuals disproportionately affected. An insult towards individuals is the most frequent cause of CtO. In general, male members and those belonging to opposition parties receive more calls to order than their female and coalition-party counterparts. Most CtO triggers were detected in speeches dedicated to governmental affairs and actions of the presidency. The CtO triggers dataset is available at: https://github.com/kalawinka/cto_analysis.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。