arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2603.21736cs.AIcs.CL
收藏

推理中的推理错误:为何不同类型的推理需要不同的表示结构

Representational Acquisition Under Bounded Resources

BridgeM, Inc.(BridgeM公司);Department of Philosophy, University of Massachusetts Amherst(马萨诸塞大学阿默斯特分校哲学系)

Yiling Wu

AI总结:

本文探讨不同推理类型对表示系统结构需求的差异,提出四个结构性质,并指出结构保证对推理类型的重要性,支持了结构重组的必要性。

摘要:

不同类型的推理对表示系统施加不同的结构性要求,但心理学、人工智能和心灵哲学领域尚无系统性的解释。本文提出一个框架,识别表示系统的四个结构性质:可操作性、一致性、结构保持性和组合性。这些性质被不同形式的推理以不同程度所要求,从归纳、类比和因果推理到演绎和形式逻辑。每个性质排除了一类特定的推理失败。分析揭示了一个主要的结构性边界:边界以下的推理类型可以操作于联想、概率性表示,而边界以上的则需要全部四个性质完全满足。在不进行结构重组的情况下扩大统计学习是不足以跨越这一边界,因为演绎推理所需的结构性保证无法通过概率手段近似。来自人工智能评估、发展心理学和认知神经科学的证据在不同层面支持了该框架。得出三个可检验的预测,包括叠加退化、对特定结构破坏的易损性以及在扩展下的不可约性。该框架是一种必要条件账户,不涉及表示格式,旨在重组现有争论而非闭合它们。

英文摘要:

A learner's obligation to keep acquired content usable imposes a storage-access tradeoff, with exact endpoints that force different physical organizations. For an exact concept-learning task, we determine the storage-read curve within a constant factor. One-read compound queries force answer-specific cells and exponentially costly updates; one-bit, order-independent updates instead force fact-specific cells. At minimum storage capacity, a robust counterpart holds: when update stretch is averaged uniformly over all semantic cube edges, small excess stretch bounds expected distance from a coordinate encoding under the uniform content distribution. It also bounds the information inaccessible to a one-read consumer. Preservation imposes further constraints. On a common invariant ready-state domain, old content preserved by ordinary zero-read overwrites must factor through the unwritten coordinates. Distributed encodings can require reading every cell to choose a preserving update. For conditional Horn reasoning, we obtain a second pair of exact endpoints: maintaining answers makes use local, while minimum storage and one-change named revision force a rule vector whose optimal query-read cost is determined exactly. These results explain how acquired distinctions, subsequent uses, and update constraints jointly determine the costs and organization of a retained resource.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑