构成性与纠正性:人类在人工智能系统运行时参与的因果分类
Constitutive vs. Corrective: A Causal Taxonomy of Human Runtime Involvement in AI Systems
AI总结:
本文提出基于因果结构的人类在AI运行时参与的分类,区分构成性与纠正性,并探讨不同时间模式和认知整合对干预能力的影响。
摘要:
随着AI系统日益渗透到高风险决策中,关于人类参与的术语如Human-in-the-Loop (HITL)、Human-on-the-Loop (HOTL) 和 Human Oversight 的模糊性带来了跨学科合作的障碍和监管不确定性。本文提出基于因果结构的澄清,认为HITL是构成性(人类贡献是决策输出的必要条件),而HOTL是纠正性(外部于主因果链,能防止或修改输出)。在HOTL中,区分三种时间模式——同步、异步和前瞻性,并在嵌套的提供者和部署者运行模型中澄清其干预能力。第二维捕捉认知整合:人类和机器作为互补或混合智能,产生四种结构不同的配置。最后,区分这些描述性类别与它们所服务的规范性要求:法定的“人类监督”是HOTL的一种特定规范性模式,要求不仅仅是纠正因果位置,而是真正的准备和干预能力。由于同一人可能同时担任HITL和HOTL角色,本文认为这种角色双重性必须作为设计问题,需要架构和知识缓解,而非简单承认。
英文摘要:
As AI systems permeate high-stakes decision-making, the terminology of human involvement---Human-in-the-Loop (HITL), Human-on-the-Loop (HOTL), and Human Oversight---has become vexingly ambiguous. This complicates interdisciplinary collaboration between computer science, law, philosophy, psychology, and sociology and breeds regulatory uncertainty. We propose a clarification grounded in causal structure, focused on runtime involvement. The distinction between HITL and HOTL is best drawn not spatially---in terms of a human's position "in" or "on" a loop---but causally: HITL is constitutive (a human contribution is necessary for the decision output), while HOTL is corrective (external to the primary causal chain, capable of preventing or modifying outputs). Within HOTL, we distinguish temporal modes---synchronous, asynchronous, and anticipatory---situated in a nested model of provider and deployer runtime. A second, orthogonal dimension captures cognitive integration: whether human and machine form complementary or hybrid intelligence, yielding four distinct configurations. Finally, we separate these descriptive categories from the normative requirements they serve: statutory "Human Oversight" is a normative mode of HOTL demanding not merely a corrective causal position but genuine preparedness and capacity for effective intervention. Because the same person may occupy both roles, this role duality must be treated as a design problem requiring architectural and epistemic mitigation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。