arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2603.18987cs.AI
收藏

揭示预测警务中的算法偏见:基于GAN的模拟框架与多城市时间分析

Spatial disparities in simulated patrol detection: a reproducible generative-model audit across Baltimore and Chicago

University of Maryland, Baltimore County(马里兰大学巴尔的摩分校);Jagannath University(贾加纳特大学)

Pronob Kumar Barman, Pronoy Kumar Barman

AI总结:

本文提出基于GAN的模拟框架,分析多城市警务中种族偏见的传播,通过实验证明算法偏见的显著性及结构性不平等的持续性。

摘要:

预测警务系统通过算法生成的犯罪预测来分配巡逻资源已在美城广泛部署,但其编码和放大种族差异的倾向在量化上仍不明确。本文提出一个可复现的模拟框架,将生成对抗网络GAN与噪声或巡逻检测模型结合,以测量种族偏见如何通过完整的执法流程传播,从犯罪发生到警察接触。利用巴尔的摩2017至2019年的145000多起第一部分犯罪记录和芝加哥2022年的233000多起记录,并结合美国人口普查ACS人口数据,计算了264种城市年模式观测下的四个月度偏见指标:差异影响比率DIR、人口平权差距、基尼系数和复合偏见放大分数。实验揭示了巴尔的摩检测模式中极端且年变的偏见,2019年平均年DIR最高达15714,芝加哥检测模式中黑色居民的检测率偏移为0.22,所有条件下基尼系数保持在0.43至0.62之间。进一步证明,条件表格GAN CTGAN去偏方法部分重新分配了检测率,但无法在无政策干预的情况下消除结构性不平等。社会经济回归分析证实,社区种族构成与检测可能性之间存在强相关性,百分比白人与百分比黑人分别呈现0.83和-0.81的相关系数。对巡逻半径、警员数量和公民报告概率的敏感性分析显示,结果最敏感于警员部署水平。代码和数据在本仓库中公开。

英文摘要:

Auditing predictive policing requires distinguishing recorded crime incidents, simulated patrol observations, and the demographic characteristics of places. We present a reproducible spatial simulation audit combining a generative adversarial network (GAN) for patrol allocation with a probabilistic detection model. Using frozen archives of 145,178 Baltimore records (2017-2019) and 234,882 Chicago records (2022), we rebuild geographic covariates from Census tract boundaries and American Community Survey data. We compare GAN allocation with empirical-location sampling and uniform-area deployment under alternative observation streams. Twenty random seeds per condition yield 560 trajectories, each covering February through December. Under detection-only training, mean detection-rate differences between Black-majority and White-majority areas range from -2.03 to 0.75 percentage points across city-years, while total coverage ranges from 1.78% to 7.50%. Paired comparisons with full-record reference trajectories assess observation feedback conditional on the recorded incident archives. In an experiment using a conditional tabular generative model for balanced synthetic replacement, geographic consistency requirements fail in 107 of 220 seed-month fits, leaving no complete annual synthetic-replacement trajectories. Simulated disparities vary with the observation process, allocation policy, training budget, and random seed. These results support reproducible comparisons of modeled scenarios but do not estimate individual racial disparities in police contact or the distribution of unrecorded crime. We recommend reporting absolute detection differences, coverage, synthesis feasibility, and simulation uncertainty alongside ratio-based fairness metrics.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑