arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2603.18677cs.HCcs.AIcs.CY
收藏

认知放大与认知委托在人机系统中的区别:一个度量框架

Cognitive Amplification vs Cognitive Delegation in Human-AI Systems: A Metric Framework

University of Colorado Boulder(科罗拉多大学波德穆尔分校)

Eduardo Di Santi, Carla Florida

AI总结:

本文提出度量框架区分认知放大与认知委托,通过定义CAI*、D、HRI和HCDR等指标,评估人机系统协同性能及人类认知可持续性。

摘要:

人工智能日益嵌入人类决策中,既能增强推理能力也可能导致过度认知依赖。本文提出概念和数学框架区分认知放大(AI提升混合人机性能并保持人类专长)与认知委托(推理逐步委托给AI系统)。定义了操作指标:认知放大指数(CAI*)、依赖比(D)、人类依赖指数(HRI)和人类认知漂移率(HCDR)。这些指标提供低维度量空间,评估人机系统是否实现真正的协同性能以及此类性能对人类组件的长期认知可持续性。框架强调人机系统的核心设计矛盾:最大化短期混合能力不必然保护长期人类认知能力。因此,主张在认知可持续性约束下设计人机系统,使混合性能提升不以人类专长退化为代价。

英文摘要:

Artificial intelligence is increasingly embedded in human decision-making, yet distinguishing systems that genuinely amplify human cognition from those promoting excessive dependence remains underdefined. This paper introduces a framework to distinguish cognitive amplification (improving hybrid performance without degrading human capability) from cognitive delegation (outsourcing reasoning to the AI). We define four metrics: the Cognitive Amplification Index (CAI*), Dependency Ratio (D), Human Reliance Index (HRI), and Human Cognitive Drift Rate (HCDR). We test this framework in an agent-based NetLogo simulation across three reliance regimes and multiple dependency-atrophy configurations, performing constrained optimizations and parameter sweeps to determine if positive collaborative gain is recoverable. Finally, we introduce an extension with an explicit human-AI interaction term. Our metrics effectively distinguish degenerate AI-dominated delegation, capability-preserving but weakly competitive interaction, and structurally dependent boundary regimes. Across all baseline configurations, no regime achieves positive collaborative gain relative to the best standalone baseline, even when reducing capability atrophy to zero. This limitation proves structural rather than merely parametric. Positive collaborative gain (CAI* > 0) becomes attainable only after introducing an explicit interaction term allowing retained human capability to contribute directly to the assisted output. This framework provides a basis for evaluating whether human-AI systems remain cognitively sustainable. The results suggest that preventing capability erosion alone is insufficient for genuine amplification if the architecture remains delegation-oriented. Amplification requires both preserved human capability and a coupling mechanism through which it contributes productively to the hybrid outcome.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑