人工智能中的突变平衡:制度扩展定律与主权人工智能的物种分化
Punctuated Equilibria in Artificial Intelligence: The Institutional Scaling Law and the Speciation of Sovereign AI
AI总结:
本文挑战人工智能发展连续进步的假设,提出基于生物进化突变平衡理论,揭示AI发展通过停滞期与快速转型交替的非单调模式,提出制度扩展定律及主权AI的物种分化概念。
摘要:
人工智能发展主流叙事假设进步连续且能力随模型规模单调增长。本文挑战此假设,基于生物进化突变平衡理论,证明AI发展并非平滑进步,而是通过长时间停滞期与快速转型交替。识别自1943年以来的五个时期及当前生成AI时代内的四个纪元,每个时期由断续事件启动。提出制度适应性曼fold框架,评估AI系统在能力、制度信任、成本和主权合规四个维度。核心结果是制度扩展定律,证明制度适应性在模型规模非单调。在环境最优后,进一步扩展会因信任损耗和成本惩罚超过边际能力增益而降级。这直接反驳经典扩展定律,暗示小型、领域适应模型在多数制度部署环境可超越前沿通用模型。推导正式条件并提供支持证据,涵盖前沿实验室动态、训练后对齐演变及主权AI作为地缘政治选择压力的兴起。
英文摘要:
The dominant narrative of artificial intelligence development assumes that progress is continuous and that capability scales monotonically with model size. We challenge both assumptions. Drawing on punctuated equilibrium theory from evolutionary biology, we show that AI development proceeds not through smooth advancement but through extended periods of stasis interrupted by rapid phase transitions that reorganize the competitive landscape. We identify five such eras since 1943 and four epochs within the current Generative AI Era, each initiated by a discontinuous event -- from the transformer architecture to the DeepSeek Moment -- that rendered the prior paradigm subordinate. To formalize the selection pressures driving these transitions, we develop the Institutional Fitness Manifold, a mathematical framework that evaluates AI systems along four dimensions: capability, institutional trust, affordability, and sovereign compliance. The central result is the Institutional Scaling Law, which proves that institutional fitness is non-monotonic in model scale. Beyond an environment-specific optimum, scaling further degrades fitness as trust erosion and cost penalties outweigh marginal capability gains. This directly contradicts classical scaling laws and carries a strong implication: orchestrated systems of smaller, domain-adapted models can mathematically outperform frontier generalists in most institutional deployment environments. We derive formal conditions under which this inversion holds and present supporting empirical evidence spanning frontier laboratory dynamics, post-training alignment evolution, and the rise of sovereign AI as a geopolitical selection pressure.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。