arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2603.06324cs.CLcs.CV
收藏

向后置的艺术:评估人工智能仿作对当代艺术作品的评估

The Art That Poses Back: Assessing AI Pastiches after Contemporary Artworks

University of Bucharest, ISDS(布加勒斯大学)

Anca Dinu, Andreiana Mihail, Andra-Maria Florescu, Claudiu Creanga

AI总结:

本研究评估AI仿照当代艺术作品的能力,发现其在风格和概念上的不足,提出使用多指标仪表盘改进评估方法。

摘要:

本研究探讨了人工视觉创造力,重点在于ChatGPT生成新图像的能力,有意仿照原始作品如绘画、素描、雕塑和装置。该过程涉及来自罗马尼亚、保加利亚、法国、奥地利和英国的十二位艺术家,每位艺术家受邀贡献三件自己的作品,并对AI生成的版本进行评分和评论。分析结合了人类评估与计算方法,旨在检测原始作品与其AI生成版本之间的视觉和风格相似性或差异性。结果指出颜色和纹理相似性与构图、概念和感知相似性之间存在显著差距。因此,我们主张使用互补指标的“风格迁移仪表盘”来评估仿作与原作之间的相似性,而非使用单一风格指标。艺术家的评论揭示了ChatGPT在仿照当代艺术作品时的局限性,这些局限性被原作作者视为缺乏维度、上下文和有意意义,显得更像是 paraphrase 或近似引用,而非有价值的、引发情感的艺术作品。

英文摘要:

This study explores artificial visual creativity, focusing on ChatGPT's ability to generate new images intentionally pastiching original artworks such as paintings, drawings, sculptures and installations. The process involved twelve artists from Romania, Bulgaria, France, Austria, and the United Kingdom, each invited to contribute with three of their artworks and to grade and comment on the AI-generated versions. The analysis combines human evaluation with computational methods aimed at detecting visual and stylistic similarities or divergences between the original works and their AI-produced renditions. The results point to a significant gap between color and texture-based similarity and compositional, conceptual, and perceptual one. Consequently, we advocate for the use of a "style transfer dashboard" of complementary metrics to evaluate the similarity between pastiches and originals, rather than using a single style metric. The artists' comments revealed limitations of ChatGPT's pastiches after contemporary artworks, which were perceived by the authors of the originals as lacking dimensionality, context, and intentional sense, and seeming more of a paraphrase or an approximate quotation rather than as a valuable, emotion-evoking artwork.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑