个人AI时代的战略建议
Strategic Advice in the Age of Personal AI
AI总结:
研究个人AI在战略建议中的影响,分析其对顾问表现和信任机制的非单调效应。
摘要:
个人AI助手改变了人们使用机构和专业建议的方式。我们研究这一新的战略环境,其中个体可能随机咨询一个个人AI,其推荐可被焦点顾问预测。个人AI进入这一战略环境有两大维度:被咨询的频率以及在被咨询时人类决策中所赋予的权重。考虑到这一点,顾问会通过对抗个人AI的推荐来回应。对抗变得越加激烈,当个人AI被咨询的频率越高。然而,顾问的表现是非单调的:在采用程度的中间水平时,均衡损失最高,当个人AI从未使用或始终使用时,均衡损失消失。信任通过一个单一的相对影响指数影响表现,个人AI的相对影响越大,顾问的脆弱性也越高。扩展该框架到有成本的信用建设,我们刻画了个人AI的采用如何重塑投资于信任的激励。
英文摘要:
Personal AI assistants are changing how individuals use advice. We study how an advisor should design its recommendation in anticipation of stochastic consultation with personal AI whose recommendation is predictable. Personal AI enters through two dimensions: consultation probability and relative trust, which captures the relative influence personal AI receives when consulted. In the baseline model, the advisor optimally counteracts the personal AI signal. Counteraction increases with consultation probability but is hump-shaped in relative trust. The advisor's minimized loss is hump-shaped in consultation probability, vanishing when personal AI is never or always consulted. Greater relative trust in personal AI increases the irreducible loss arising from stochastic consultation. We extend the analysis to partial predictability and costly recommendation adjustment, characterizing their effects on optimal recommendations and minimized loss. The framework also accommodates richer information structures, including settings in which personal AI is perceived as having access to private information relevant to the task. We introduce an online forecasting experiment that examines how participants obtain personal AI advice and combine it with an advisor's recommendation and their initial judgments. Participants place weight on all three inputs. When access requires an additional action, some participants do not seek personal AI advice, while some others attempt to obtain it without success. Together, these findings highlight two distinct aspects of personal AI use: whether advice is obtained and how much weight it receives when available.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。