基于图的多组学整合在TCGA-BRCA中优于经典整合策略的亚型恢复和生存预测
Graph-Based Multi-Omics Integration Improves Subtype Recovery and Survival Prediction Over Classical Integration Strategies in TCGA-BRCA
AI总结:
基于图的多组学整合在TCGA-BRCA中优于经典整合策略,提升了亚型恢复和生存预测性能。
摘要:
背景。乳腺癌至少包含五个分子亚型,具有不同的预后,但PAM50分类仅依赖转录组学数据。是否整合DNA甲基化和拷贝数数据能够改善亚型恢复和生存预测仍是一个开放性问题。 方法。我们应用相似性网络融合(SNF)对n=644名TCGA-BRCA患者进行了分析,这些患者具有匹配的RNA测序、450k DNA甲基化和GISTIC2拷贝数谱。每种模态的患者相似性网络被迭代融合(K=20,T=20,u=0.5),并通过谱聚类进行划分;k=2在特征间隙和轮廓系数标准下预先指定。SNF被与RNA-only、拷贝数变异-only、甲基化-only以及早期拼接基线进行了比较,使用PAM50 NMI进行亚型恢复,并使用Ridge Cox模型的Out-of-fold一致性指数(OOF C-index)进行生存预测,N=1,000次bootstrap置信区间用于成对比较。 结果。SNF产生了一个稳定的两簇划分(稳定性ARI=1.00,轮廓系数=0.228),NMI=0.495,比PAM50高,超过RNA-only(0.428)和早期拼接(0.175)。IHC受体数据证实了簇生物学独立验证(ER+:92.8% vs 15.6%;三阴性:1.0% vs 45.4%;两者p<10^-100)。SNF实现了OOF C-index为0.681(95%CI 0.610-0.760),显著优于拷贝数变异-only(Delta=+0.122,CI 0.020-0.211);其相对于RNA-only的优势(Delta=+0.049,CI -0.036-0.144)并未排除零。 结论。基于图的多组学融合比特征拼接更忠实恢复乳腺癌亚型生物学,且在生存预测上优于最弱的单模态基线。SNF相对于RNA测序的优势方向是正的,但在此样本量下尚未统计学上明确,这指出了整合复杂性和所需样本量之间权衡的问题。
英文摘要:
Background. Breast cancer comprises at least five molecular subtypes with distinct prognoses, yet PAM50 classification relies on transcriptomics alone. Whether integrating DNA methylation and copy number data improves subtype recovery and survival prediction over single-omic baselines remains an open question. Methods. We applied Similarity Network Fusion (SNF) to n = 644 TCGA-BRCA patients with matched RNA-seq, 450k DNA methylation, and GISTIC2 copy number profiles. Per-modality patient similarity networks were iteratively fused (K = 20, T = 20, u = 0.5) and partitioned by spectral clustering; k = 2 was pre-specified on eigengap and silhouette criteria. SNF was benchmarked against RNA-only, CNV-only, methylation-only, and early concatenation baselines using PAM50 NMI for subtype recovery and out-of-fold concordance index (OOF C-index) from a Ridge Cox model with N = 1,000 bootstrap CIs for pairwise comparisons. Results. SNF produced a stable two-cluster partition (stability ARI = 1.00, silhouette = 0.228), with NMI = 0.495 versus PAM50, exceeding RNA-only (0.428) and early concatenation (0.175). IHC receptor data confirmed cluster biology independently (ER+: 92.8% vs 15.6%; triple-negative: 1.0% vs 45.4%; both p < 10^-100). SNF achieved an OOF C-index of 0.681 (95% CI 0.610-0.760), significantly outperforming CNV-only (Delta = +0.122, CI 0.020-0.211); the advantage over RNA-only (Delta = +0.049, CI -0.036-0.144) did not exclude zero. Conclusion. Graph-based multi-omics fusion recovers breast cancer subtype biology more faithfully than feature concatenation and outperforms the weakest unimodal baselines in survival prediction. The improvement over RNA-seq alone is positive in direction but not yet statistically conclusive at this cohort size, pointing to the trade-off between integration complexity and the sample sizes needed to quantify its marginal benefit.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。