PEERfect REVIEWer 的伦理:科学关怀与同事福利
The Ethos of the PEERfect REVIEWer: Scientific Care and Collegial Welfare
AI总结:
本文提出PEERfect REVIEWer的伦理,强调科学关怀与同事福利,通过16条建议指导评审员以更建设性的方式提升同行评审质量。
摘要:
同行评审仍然是学术界的重要基石,但其在促进共同进步和福祉方面经常表现不佳。尽管同行评审主要强调科学严谨性,但往往缺乏支持和鼓励所有参与者的同理心。在本经验报告中,我旨在强调同行评审是一种既要求对质量进行科学关怀,又要求为所有参与者的共同进步和福祉服务的实践,包括作者、共同评审者、研讨会或会议组织者以及期刊编辑。基于我在学术界十年的经验,我提出了PEERfect REVIEWer的伦理,其基于两个核心价值:科学关怀和同事福利。通过专业交流中形成的反思、文献的考虑以及对自撰和接收的评审的审查,我制定了一套包含16项实用建议的指南,以指导评审员在行动中实现这两个价值。PEERfect REVIEWer的伦理及其配套指南帮助评审员在维持高标准科学标准的同时,以建设性、支持性、尊重和及时的方式进行同行评审。它们表明,科学严谨性和同理心是互补的力量,促进有影响力的同行评审实践。通过将科学关怀和同事福利置于同行评审的核心,本经验报告重新确认了科学严谨性的重要性,同时倡导对同理心给予更多关注。它邀请评审员重新考虑他们的角色,不仅作为守门人,而是作为每位参与者的学术旅程中的伙伴。PEERfect REVIEWer既是质量的守护者,也是共同进步和福祉的守护者——真正有影响力的同行评审实践需要科学严谨性和同理心同等重视。
英文摘要:
Peer review remains a cornerstone in academia, yet it frequently falls short in fostering joint progress and well-being. While peer review primarily emphasizes scientific rigor, it often lacks the empathy essential for supporting and encouraging all peers involved. In this experience report, I aim to highlight that peer review is a practice that demands both scientific care for quality and collegial welfare for the joint progress and well-being of all peers involved, including authors, co-reviewers, workshop or conference organizers, and journal editors. Drawing on my ten years of experience in academia, I propose the ethos of the PEERfect REVIEWer, grounded in the two core values: Scientific care and collegial welfare. Through reflection shaped by professional exchanges with colleagues, consideration of literature, and an examination of both self-authored and received reviews, I formulated an accompanying guideline with 16 practical recommendations to guide reviewers in their actions to achieve these two values. The ethos of the PEERfect REVIEWer and its accompanying guideline help reviewers in upholding high scientific standards and conducting peer review in a constructive, supportive, respectful, and timely manner. They demonstrate that scientific rigor and empathy are complementary forces that promote impactful peer review practice. By placing scientific care and collegial welfare at the core of peer review, this experience report reaffirms the importance of scientific rigor while also advocating for greater attention to empathy. It invites reviewers to reconsider their role not merely as gatekeepers but as partners in the academic journey of each peer involved. The PEERfect REVIEWer is both a caretaker of quality and a steward of joint progress and well-being - as truly impactful peer review practice requires scientific rigor and empathy in equal measure.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。