评估电子商务网站对个人数据保护法的合规性:来自人类和LLM分析的见解与教训
Evaluating PDPL Compliance in E-Commerce Websites: Insights and Lessons Learned from Human and LLM Analyses
AI总结:
本文分析了沙特阿拉伯100家电子商务网站对PDPL的合规性,发现仅有31%的网站完整声明了四项个人数据权利,且LLM在自动分析隐私政策合规性方面具有潜力。
摘要:
2024年,沙特阿拉伯的《个人数据保护法》(PDPL)正式实施。然而,关于其实施的评估工作很少。本文分析了100家在沙特阿拉伯运营的电子商务网站,检查其隐私政策中四项个人数据权利和实践的声明:1)个人数据保留期限,2)请求删除个人数据的权利,3)请求复制个人数据的权利,4)投诉机制。我们的结果表明,尽管国家意识和支持努力,我们数据集中相当大的电子商务网站并未完全合规:只有31%的网站在隐私政策中声明了所有四项。即使隐私政策包含这些声明,相当一部分未能涵盖所需的细粒度细节。第二,我们数据集中排名靠前的电子商务网站和那些托管在本地电子商务平台上的网站,其非合规率显著高于中低排名网站和未托管在本地平台的网站。第三,我们评估了大型语言模型(LLM)作为自动工具用于隐私政策分析,以衡量PDPL的合规性。我们强调LLM的潜力,并建议改进基于LLM的自动分析方法。我们的结果为理解数据保护法律实施障碍提供了进展,特别是在非西方背景下。我们为政策制定者、监管机构、网站所有者和开发者提供了改进建议,以提高数据保护实践并自动化合规监控。
英文摘要:
In 2024, Saudi Arabia's Personal Data Protection Law (PDPL) came into force. However, little work has been done to assess its implementation. In this paper, we analyzed 100 e-commerce websites operating in Saudi Arabia against the PDPL, examining the presence of a privacy policy and, if present, the policy's declarations of four items pertaining to personal data rights and practices: 1) personal data retention period, 2) the right to request the destruction of personal data, 3) the right to request a copy of personal data, and 4) a mechanism for filing complaints. Our results show that, despite national awareness and support efforts, a significant fraction of e-commerce websites in our dataset are not fully compliant with the examined PDPL requirements at the privacy policy level: only 31% of websites in our dataset declared all four examined items in their privacy policies. Second, the majority of top-ranked e-commerce websites in our dataset (based on search results order) and those hosted on local e-commerce hosting platforms exhibited significantly higher non-compliance rates than mid- to low-ranked websites and those not hosted on local e-commerce platforms. Third, we explored the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) as an automated tool for privacy policy analysis to measure compliance with the PDPL, using the GPT-5 model. We highlight the potential of LLMs and suggest considerations that can inform future benchmarks aimed at improving LLM-based automated analysis for privacy policies. Our results provide a step forward in understanding implementation barriers to data protection laws, especially in non-Western contexts. We provide recommendations for policymakers, regulators, website owners, and developers seeking to improve data protection practices and automate compliance monitoring.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。