Particle smoothing enables state estimation in nonlinear and non-Gaussian state-space models, but its practical use is often limited by high computational cost. Backward smoothing methods such as the Forward Filter Backward Smoother (FFBS) and its marginal form (FFBSm) can achieve high accuracy, yet typically require quadratic computational complexity in the number of particles. This paper examines the accuracy--computational cost trade-offs of particle smoothing methods through a trend-estimation example. Fixed-lag smoothing, FFBS, and FFBSm are compared under Gaussian and heavy-tailed (Cauchy-type) system noise, with particular attention to O(m) approximations of FFBSm based on subsampling and local neighborhood restrictions. The results show that FFBS and FFBSm outperform fixed-lag smoothing at a fixed particle number, while fixed-lag smoothing often achieves higher accuracy under equal computational time. Moreover, efficient FFBSm approximations are effective for Gaussian transitions but become less advantageous for heavy-tailed dynamics.
In the context of state-space models, skeleton-based smoothing algorithms rely on a backward sampling step which by default has a $\mathcal O(N^2)$ complexity (where $N$ is the number of particles). Existing improvements in the literature are unsatisfactory: a popular rejection sampling -- based approach, as we shall show, might lead to badly behaved execution time; another rejection sampler with stopping lacks complexity analysis; yet another MCMC-inspired algorithm comes with no stability guarantee. We provide several results that close these gaps. In particular, we prove a novel non-asympto…
We consider the problem of state estimation in general state-space models using variational inference. For a generic variational family defined using the same backward decomposition as the actual joint smoothing distribution, we establish for the first time that, under mixing assumptions, the variational approximation of expectations of additive state functionals induces an error which grows at most linearly in the number of observations. This guarantee is consistent with the known upper bounds for the approximation of smoothing distributions using standard Monte Carlo methods. Moreover, we pr…
In this article we consider the smoothing problem for hidden Markov models (HMM). Given a hidden Markov chain $\{X_n\}_{n\geq 0}$ and observations $\{Y_n\}_{n\geq 0}$, our objective is to compute $\mathbb{E}[φ(X_0,\dots,X_k)|y_{0},\dots,y_n]$ for some real-valued, integrable functional $φ$ and $k$ fixed, $k \ll n$ and for some realisation $(y_0,\dots,y_n)$ of $(Y_0,\dots,Y_n)$. We introduce a novel application of the multilevel Monte Carlo (MLMC) method with a coupling based on the Knothe-Rosenblatt rearrangement. We prove that this method can approximate the afore-mentioned quantity with a me…
Smoothing in state-space models amounts to computing the conditional distribution of the latent state trajectory, given observations, or expectations of functionals of the state trajectory with respect to this distributions. For models that are not linear Gaussian or possess finite state space, smoothing distributions are in general infeasible to compute as they involve intergrals over a space of dimensionality at least equal to the number of observations. Recent years have seen an increased interest in Monte Carlo-based methods for smoothing, often involving particle filters. One such method …
This paper focuses on Sequential Monte Carlo approximations of smoothing distributions in conditionally linear and Gaussian state spaces. To reduce Monte Carlo variance of smoothers, it is typical in these models to use Rao-Blackwellization: particle approximation is used to sample sequences of hidden regimes while the Gaussian states are explicitly integrated conditional on the sequence of regimes and observations, using variants of the Kalman filter / smoother. The first successful attempt to use Rao-Blackwellization for smoothing extends the Bryson-Frazier smoother for Gaussian linear state…
This paper presents an algorithm for Monte Carlo fixed-lag smoothing in state-space models defined by a diffusion process observed through noisy discrete-time measurements. Based on a particles approximation of the filtering and smoothing distributions, the method relies on a simulation technique of conditioned diffusions. The proposed sequential smoother can be applied to general non linear and multidimensional models, like the ones used in environmental applications. The smoothing of a turbulent flow in a high-dimensional context is given as a practical example.
We present a novel sequential Monte Carlo approach to online smoothing of additive functionals in a very general class of path-space models. Hitherto, the solutions proposed in the literature suffer from either long-term numerical instability due to particle-path degeneracy or, in the case that degeneracy is remedied by particle approximation of the so-called backward kernel, high computational demands. In order to balance optimally computational speed against numerical stability, we propose to furnish a (fast) naive particle smoother, propagating recursively a sample of particles and associat…
Sequential Monte Carlo (SMC) methods are a widely used set of computational tools for inference in non-linear non-Gaussian state-space models. We propose a new SMC algorithm to compute the expectation of additive functionals recursively. Essentially, it is an online or forward-only implementation of a forward filtering backward smoothing SMC algorithm proposed in Doucet .et .al (2000). Compared to the standard path space SMC estimator whose asymptotic variance increases quadratically with time even under favourable mixing assumptions, the asymptotic variance of the proposed SMC estimator only …
The conditional particle filter (CPF) is a promising algorithm for general hidden Markov model smoothing. Empirical evidence suggests that the variant of CPF with backward sampling (CBPF) performs well even with long time series. Previous theoretical results have not been able to demonstrate the improvement brought by backward sampling, whereas we provide rates showing that CBPF can remain effective with a fixed number of particles independent of the time horizon. Our result is based on analysis of a new coupling of two CBPFs, the coupled conditional backward sampling particle filter (CCBPF). …
We propose two new Bayesian smoothing methods for general state-space models with unknown parameters. The first approach is based on the particle learning and smoothing algorithm, but with an adjustment in the backward resampling weights. The second is a new method combining sequential parameter learning and smoothing algorithms for general state-space models. This method is straightforward but effective, and we find it is the best existing Sequential Monte Carlo algorithm to solve the joint Bayesian smoothing problem. We first illustrate the methods on three benchmark models using simulated d…
Particle smoothing methods are used for inference of stochastic processes based on noisy observations. Typically, the estimation of the marginal posterior distribution given all observations is cumbersome and computational intensive. In this paper, we propose a simple algorithm based on path integral control theory to estimate the smoothing distribution of continuous-time diffusion processes with partial observations. In particular, we use an adaptive importance sampling method to improve the effective sampling size of the posterior over processes given the observations and the reliability of …
Gerber and Chopin (2015) recently introduced Sequential quasi-Monte Carlo (SQMC) algorithms as an efficient way to perform filtering in state-space models. The basic idea is to replace random variables with low-discrepancy point sets, so as to obtain faster convergence than with standard particle filtering. Gerber and Chopin (2015) describe briefly several ways to extend SQMC to smoothing, but do not provide supporting theory for this extension. We discuss more thoroughly how smoothing may be performed within SQMC, and derive convergence results for the so-obtained smoothing algorithms. We con…
Sequential Monte Carlo (SMC) methods, such as the particle filter, are by now one of the standard computational techniques for addressing the filtering problem in general state-space models. However, many applications require post-processing of data offline. In such scenarios the smoothing problem--in which all the available data is used to compute state estimates--is of central interest. We consider the smoothing problem for a class of conditionally linear Gaussian models. We present a forward-backward-type Rao-Blackwellized particle smoother (RBPS) that is able to exploit the tractable subst…
Columbia University（哥伦比亚大学）；Cornell University（康奈尔大学）
A body of recent work has focused on constructing a variational family of filtered distributions using Sequential Monte Carlo (SMC). Inspired by this work, we introduce Particle Smoothing Variational Objectives (SVO), a novel backward simulation technique and smoothed approximate posterior defined through a subsampling process. SVO augments support of the proposal and boosts particle diversity. Recent literature argues that increasing the number of samples K to obtain tighter variational bounds may hurt the proposal learning, due to a signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of gradient estimators decreasi…
We consider the problem of high-dimensional filtering of state-space models (SSMs) at discrete times. This problem is particularly challenging as analytical solutions are typically not available and many numerical approximation methods can have a cost that scales exponentially with the dimension of the hidden state. Inspired by lag-approximation methods for the smoothing problem, we introduce a lagged approximation of the smoothing distribution that is necessarily biased. For certain classes of SSMs, particularly those that forget the initial condition exponentially fast in time, the bias of o…
We present a novel method in the family of particle MCMC methods that we refer to as particle Gibbs with ancestor sampling (PG-AS). Similarly to the existing PG with backward simulation (PG-BS) procedure, we use backward sampling to (considerably) improve the mixing of the PG kernel. Instead of using separate forward and backward sweeps as in PG-BS, however, we achieve the same effect in a single forward sweep. We apply the PG-AS framework to the challenging class of non-Markovian state-space models. We develop a truncation strategy of these models that is applicable in principle to any backwa…
"Particle methods" are sequential Monte Carlo algorithms, typically involving importance sampling, that are used to estimate and sample from joint and marginal densities from a collection of a, presumably increasing, number of random variables. In particular, a particle filter aims to estimate the current state $X_{n}$ of a stochastic system that is not directly observable by estimating a posterior distribution $π(x_{n}|y_{1},y_{2}, \ldots, y_{n})$ where the $\{Y_{n}\}$ are observations related to the $\{X_{n}\}$ through some measurement model $π(y_{n}|x_{n})$. A particle smoother aims to esti…
We introduce a novel method for online smoothing in state-space models that utilises a fixed-lag approximation to overcome the well known issue of path degeneracy. Unlike classical fixed-lag techniques that only approximate certain marginals, we introduce an online resampling algorithm, called particle stitching, that converts these marginal samples into a full posterior approximation. We demonstrate the utility of our method in the context of map-matching, the task of inferring a vehicle's trajectory given a road network and noisy GPS observations. We develop a new state-space model for the d…
We propose an approximation to the forward-filter-backward-sampler (FFBS) algorithm for large-scale spatio-temporal smoothing. FFBS is commonly used in Bayesian statistics when working with linear Gaussian state-space models, but it requires inverting covariance matrices which have the size of the latent state vector. The computational burden associated with this operation effectively prohibits its applications in high-dimensional settings. We propose a scalable spatio-temporal FFBS approach based on the hierarchical Vecchia approximation of Gaussian processes, which has been previously succes…
