匹配后双向固定效应估计
Post-Matching Two-Way Fixed Effects Estimation
AI总结:
本文提出匹配后差异-in-差异估计方法,解决双向固定效应模型中因处理时间不同导致的偏误问题,并推导有效标准误差。
摘要:
在使用双向固定效应(2WFE)模型估计处理效应时,研究者常在平行趋势假设被认为在协变量条件下成立时,使用匹配作为预处理步骤。具体来说,在第一步中,每个处理单位根据观察到的时间不变协变量与一个或多个未处理单位进行匹配。在第二步中,使用匹配样本中的2WFE回归估计处理效应,并通过未处理单位被匹配的次数重新加权。我们正式分析了这种常见做法,并突显了两个问题。首先,当不同处理群体进入处理的时间期不同时,将所有处理群体合并的匹配后2WFE估计量存在渐近偏误,即使处理效应在单位和时间上都是恒定的。其次,未能考虑匹配过程引入的变异性会导致无效的标准误差估计量,这些估计量可能根据数据生成过程向上或向下偏倚。我们提出了简单的匹配后差异-in-差异估计量,将每个处理群体与从未处理的群体进行比较,而不是合并所有处理群体。我们提供了这些估计量在一致估计well-defined因果参数的条件下,并推导出考虑匹配步骤的合法标准误差。我们通过模拟和实证应用来说明我们的结果。
英文摘要:
When estimating treatment effects with two-way fixed effects (2WFE) models, researchers often use matching as a pre-processing step when the parallel trends assumption is thought to hold conditionally on covariates. Specifically, in a first step, each treated unit is matched to one or more untreated units based on observed time-invariant covariates. In the second step, treatment effects are estimated with a 2WFE regression in the matched sample, reweighting the untreated units by the number of times they are matched. We formally analyze this common practice and highlight two problems. First, when different treatment cohorts enter treatment in different time periods, the post-matching 2WFE estimator that pools all treated cohorts has an asymptotic bias, even when the treatment effect is constant across units and over time. Second, failing to account for the variability introduced by the matching procedure yields invalid standard error estimators, which can be biased upwards or downwards depending on the data generating process. We propose simple post-matching difference-in-differences estimators that compare each treated cohort to the never-treated separately, instead of pooling all treated cohorts. We provide conditions under which these estimators are consistent for well-defined causal parameters, and derive valid standard errors that account for the matching step. We illustrate our results with simulations and with an empirical application.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。