人工智能在工作与个人生活中的准确性标准:来自在线调查的证据
Accuracy Standards for AI at Work vs. Personal Life: Evidence from an Online Survey
AI总结:
研究发现,用户在工作场合对AI准确性要求显著高于个人生活,且AI不可用时对个人生活影响更大。
摘要:
我们研究了人们在使用人工智能工具进行采纳时如何在专业和私人情境中权衡准确性,以及这些权衡的决定因素,以及当AI应用程序不可用时用户如何应对。由于现代AI系统(尤其是生成模型)可以产生可接受但非相同输出,我们将“准确性”定义为情境特定的可靠性:输出与用户意图一致的程度,这取决于容忍阈值,该阈值取决于利益相关者和更正成本。在一项在线调查(N=300)中,受访者中具有准确性项目(N=170)的比例中,要求高准确性的比例在工作场合为24.1%,在个人生活中为8.8%(+15.3个百分点;z=6.29,p<0.001)。在更广泛的前两箱定义下,差距仍然很大(67.0% vs. 32.9%),在完整的1-5次序尺度上(均值3.86 vs. 3.08)。重应用使用和经验模式与更严格的工作标准(H2)相关。当工具不可用(H3)时,受访者报告在个人生活中的干扰比在工作中的更大(34.1% vs. 15.3%,p<0.01)。我们保持正文专注于这些实质性结果,并将测试分类法和功率推导放在技术附录中。
英文摘要:
We study how people trade off accuracy when using AI-powered tools in professional versus personal contexts for adoption purposes, the determinants of those trade-offs, and how users cope when AI/apps are unavailable. Because modern AI systems (especially generative models) can produce acceptable but non-identical outputs, we define "accuracy" as context-specific reliability: the degree to which an output aligns with the user's intent within a tolerance threshold that depends on stakes and the cost of correction. In an online survey (N=300), among respondents with both accuracy items (N=170), the share requiring high accuracy (top-box) is 24.1% at work vs. 8.8% in personal life (+15.3 pp; z=6.29, p<0.001). The gap remains large under a broader top-two-box definition (67.0% vs. 32.9%) and on the full 1-5 ordinal scale (mean 3.86 vs. 3.08). Heavy app use and experience patterns correlate with stricter work standards (H2). When tools are unavailable (H3), respondents report more disruption in personal routines than at work (34.1% vs. 15.3%, p<0.01). We keep the main text focused on these substantive results and place test taxonomy and power derivations in a technical appendix.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。