arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2602.12749cs.HC
收藏

SoK:理解扩展现实技术在幼儿教育中的教学、健康、伦理和隐私挑战

SoK: Understanding the Pedagogical, Health, Ethical, and Privacy Challenges of Extended Reality in Early Childhood Education

Coventry University(考文垂大学);George Mason University(乔治梅森大学)

Supriya Khadka, Sanchari Das

AI总结:

本文通过系统化研究揭示扩展现实技术在幼儿教育中面临的主要挑战,并提出以儿童为中心的XR设计路线图。

摘要:

扩展现实(XR)结合了密集感知、实时渲染和近距离交互,使其在幼儿教育中的应用既具有前景又存在高风险。为了探讨这一问题,我们对111篇同行评审的文献进行了知识系统化(SoK)研究,这些文献涉及3-8岁的儿童,量化了技术、教学、健康、隐私和公平性挑战在实践中如何产生。我们发现,增强现实(AR)主导了该领域(73%),主要集中在平板电脑或手机上,而虚拟现实(VR)仍较为罕见,通常依赖头戴式显示器(HMDs)。我们将这些定量模式整合到一个联合风险和注意力矩阵以及一个增强人类发展(AHD)模型中,该模型将XR流程属性与认知负荷、感官冲突和访问不平等问题联系起来。最后,我们采用一个七维编码方案,在0-2的范围内进行评分,得出教学的平均学术关注度为1.56,隐私(主要为程序性同意)为1.04,技术可靠性为0.96,低资源环境中的可访问性为0.92,医疗和健康问题为0.81,残疾人士的可访问性为0.52,数据安全实践为0.14。这表明教学受到了最系统的审查,而数据访问实践则被忽视。我们最后提出了一条以儿童为中心的XR路线图,帮助人机交互(HCI)研究人员和教育工作者超越新颖性,设计出与儿童发展相适应、默认安全且能为多样化学习者服务的系统。

英文摘要:

Extended Reality (XR) combines dense sensing, real-time rendering, and close-range interaction, making its use in early childhood education both promising and high risk. To investigate this, we conduct a Systematization of Knowledge (SoK) of 111 peer-reviewed studies with children aged 3-8, quantifying how technical, pedagogical, health, privacy, and equity challenges arise in practice. We found that AR dominates the landscape (73%), focusing primarily on tablets or phones, while VR remains uncommon and typically relies on head mounted displays (HMDs). We integrate these quantitative patterns into a joint risk and attention matrix and an Augmented Human Development (AHD) model that link XR pipeline properties to cognitive load, sensory conflict, and access inequity. Finally, implementing a seven dimension coding scheme on a 0 - 2 scale, we obtain mean scholarly attention scores of 1.56 for pedagogy, 1.04 for privacy (primarily procedural consent), 0.96 for technical reliability, 0.92 for accessibility in low resource contexts, 0.81 for medical and health issues, 0.52 for accessibility for disabilities, and 0.14 for data security practices. This indicates that pedagogy receives the most systematic scrutiny, while data access practices is largely overlooked. We conclude by offering a roadmap for Child-Centered XR that helps HCI researchers and educators move beyond novelty to design systems that are developmentally aligned, secure by default, and accessible to diverse learners.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑