政策中物理学知识的选择性使用:跨学科物理学如何连接子领域并塑造政策影响
The selective use of physics knowledge in policy: how interdisciplinary physics bridges subfields and shapes policy influence
AI总结:
本研究探讨了物理学知识在政策中的选择性使用,发现跨学科物理学在连接子领域中起关键作用,但并不直接提升政策影响力,而地球物理学因气候问题的政治重要性更易产生影响。
摘要:
科学知识已成为政策制定的核心,因为社会面临技术变革、气候风险和公共健康等挑战。尽管证据导向政策日益受到重视,但对科学如何在政策中选择性使用的系统理解仍然有限,特别是哪些形式的知识被优先考虑,哪些科学引用转化为影响力。我们通过构建一个将Overton数据库中的政策文件与美国物理学会的出版物联系起来的新数据集,来解决这些问题,从而分析物理学知识如何进入并流通于政策话语中。利用子领域分类,我们提供了科学界与政策制定者之间存在差距的定量证据。首先,我们发现政策文件依赖于广泛的跨学科物理学领域,如普通物理学和跨学科物理学,而不是反映物理学研究生产的结构。其次,我们识别出存在显著的制度异质性,不同政策生产组织和主题在子领域偏好上存在系统性差异。第三,网络分析显示,跨学科物理学领域在连接专门子领域中起着核心桥梁作用。最后,回归分析显示政策可见性与政策影响力之间存在明显分离。虽然跨学科领域有助于进入政策话语,但并不必然增加下游政策影响力。相反,引用地球物理学的文件与政策影响力高出约24%,这可能是由于气候变化政策的政治重要性。我们的发现强调了科学可见性与政策影响力之间的区别,有助于更深入地理解科学界与政策系统之间的复杂关系。
英文摘要:
Scientific knowledge has become central to policymaking as societies face challenges related to technological change, climate risk, and public health. Despite the growing emphasis on evidence-based policy, a systematic understanding of how science is selectively used in policy, specifically which forms of knowledge are preferred and which scientific citations translate into influence, remains limited. We address these questions by constructing a novel dataset that links policy documents from the Overton database with publications from the American Physical Society, enabling an analysis of how physics knowledge enters and circulates in policy discourse. Using subfield classifications, we provide quantitative evidence for a gap between scientific communities and policymakers. First, we find that policy documents draw on broad and interdisciplinary areas of physics, such as General Physics and Interdisciplinary Physics, rather than mirroring the structure of physics research production. Second, we identify substantial institutional heterogeneity with systematic differences in subfield preferences across policy producing organizations and topics. Third, network analysis reveals that interdisciplinary areas of physics act as a central bridge connecting specialized subfields. Finally, regression analysis reveals a clear separation between policy visibility and policy influence. While interdisciplinary areas facilitate entry into policy discourse, it does not necessarily increase downstream policy influence. Conversely, documents citing geophysics are associated with approximately 24 percent higher policy influence, likely driven by the political salience of climate change policy. Our findings underscore the distinction between scientific visibility and policy influence, contributing to a deeper understanding of the complex relationship between scientific communities and policy system.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。