双重劣势:性别与居住地如何影响巴基斯坦IT行业的招聘结果
Double Disadvantage: How Gender and Residential Location Shape Hiring Outcomes in Pakistan's IT Sector
AI总结:
本文研究性别和居住地对巴基斯坦IT行业招聘结果的影响,发现男性和高收入地区候选人更具优势,即使在无明确偏见的情况下。
摘要:
本文通过巴基斯坦卡拉奇市的一项实地实验,探讨性别和居住地社会经济地位如何影响信息科技行业的招聘结果。在巴基斯坦,雇主可以公开表达对性别、居住地和其他特征的偏好,但信息科技行业大多数雇主并不这样做。这为研究在没有明确表达偏见的情况下歧视是否仍然存在提供了机会。对明确以性别为定向的招聘信息的分析显示,在大多数职业中,男性比女性更受青睐,即使是在传统上由女性从事的岗位上。此外,通过对2032份简历进行审计实验,向508个全职职位提交申请,结果显示,即使在没有明确性别偏好的招聘信息中,男性也比女性获得更多的面试回拨。该研究还表明,来自高收入地区的人士比来自低收入社区的人士获得更多的回拨,前者比后者多45%。这种优势在控制通勤距离后仍然稳固。与人力资源官员的定性访谈表明,雇主将生产力与性别和居住地社会经济地位联系在一起。居住地址作为阶级背景的代理,信号教育、技能和在专业场合中的“适配度”。这些看法可能强化刻板印象,使女性和来自低收入背景的候选人处于不利地位。
英文摘要:
This paper examines how gender and residential socioeconomic status shape hiring outcomes in the information technology sector using a field experiment from the city of Karachi, Pakistan. Employers in Pakistan can openly state preferences regarding gender, residential location, and other characteristics, but the majority in the information technology sector choose not to do so. This creates an opportunity to examine whether discrimination persists when such biases are not explicitly stated. An analysis of explicitly gender-targeted job ads shows that men are preferred over women across most occupations, even in traditionally pink-collar roles. Moreover, results from a resume audit experiment, submitting 2,032 applications to 508 full-time job openings, show that men receive more callbacks for job interviews than women, even in the absence of explicit gender preferences in job ads. The study also indicates a significant premium favoring candidates from high-income areas, who receive 45 percent more callbacks than applicants from low-income neighborhoods. This advantage remains robust even after controlling for commuting distance. Qualitative interviews with human resource officials suggest that employers associate productivity with both gender and neighborhood socioeconomic status. Residential address acts as a proxy for class background and signals education, skills, and perceived "fit" in professional settings. These perceptions may reinforce stereotypes, disadvantaging women and candidates from low-income backgrounds.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。