arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.03286cs.AIcs.MA
收藏

基于怀疑的结构双极论证中的论点拒绝

Rejecting Arguments Based on Doubt in Structured Bipolar Argumentation

Université de Fribourg(弗里堡大学);CRIL CNRS Univ Artois(CRIL CNRS阿维尼昂大学);Univ Lyon, UCBL, CNRS, INSA Lyon, LIRIS, UMR5205(里昂大学、UCBL、CNRS、INSA里昂、LIRIS、UMR5205)

Michael A. Müller, Srdjan Vesic, Bruno Yun

AI总结:

本文提出了一种基于怀疑的结构双极论证方法,允许智能体合理拒绝论点,并引入了新的语义框架来处理句子和论点的接受问题。

摘要:

本文提出了一种新的计算论证方法,受到哲学和语言学观点的启发。具体而言,它考虑了在计算论证文献中较少受到关注的两个想法:首先,一个智能体可能基于单纯的怀疑合理地拒绝一个论点,因此他们能够辩护的所有论点并不都需要被接受;其次,有时更自然的是考虑智能体在辩论中接受的个别句子或主张,而不是接受的论点。为了将这两个想法纳入计算方法中,我们首先定义了结构双极论证框架(SBAFs),其中论点由句子组成,并且在它们之间存在攻击和支持关系。然后,我们为SBAFs提供了两种特征的语义:(1)与基于完整性的语义不同,我们的语义不强制智能体接受所有被辩护的论点。(2)除了提供论点扩展(给出可接受的论点集)外,我们还提供了语言扩展的语义,以指定可接受的句子集。这些语义代表了智能体在辩论中可能持有的合理立场。我们的语义介于抽象论证的可接受和完整语义之间。此外,我们的方法可以用于为现有方法提供新的视角。例如,我们可以指定智能体在什么条件下可以忽略论点之间的支持(即在什么情况下使用抽象论证是合理的),并证明演绎支持语义是我们的方法的一个特殊情况。

英文摘要:

This paper develops a new approach to computational argumentation that is informed by philosophical and linguistic views. Namely, it takes into account two ideas that have received little attention in the literature on computational argumentation: First, an agent may rationally reject an argument based on mere doubt, thus not all arguments they could defend must be accepted; and, second, that it is sometimes more natural to think in terms of which individual sentences or claims an agent accepts in a debate, rather than which arguments. In order to incorporate these two ideas into a computational approach, we first define the notion of structured bipolar argumentation frameworks (SBAFs), where arguments consist of sentences and we have both an attack and a support relation between them. Then, we provide semantics for SBAFs with two features: (1) Unlike with completeness-based semantics, our semantics do not force agents to accept all defended arguments. (2) In addition to argument extensions, which give acceptable sets of arguments, we also provide semantics for language extensions that specify acceptable sets of sentences. These semantics represent reasonable positions an agent might have in a debate. Our semantics lie between the admissible and complete semantics of abstract argumentation. Further, our approach can be used to provide a new perspective on existing approaches. For instance, we can specify the conditions under which an agent can ignore support between arguments (i.e. under which the use of abstract argumentation is warranted) and we show that deductive support semantics is a special case of our approach.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑