arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.01933cs.AI
收藏

大语言模型与形式概念分析:一种用于主题建模的比较研究

Large Language Model and Formal Concept Analysis: a comparative study for Topic Modeling

EFRITS

Fabrice Boissier, Monica Sen, Irina Rychkova

AI总结:

本研究比较大语言模型与形式概念分析在主题建模中的应用,通过实验评估两者在生成和标注主题方面的性能与优劣。

摘要:

主题建模是一个应用日益广泛的研究领域:从历史上文档检索,到情感分析和文本摘要。大语言模型(LLM)目前是文本处理的主要趋势,但很少有研究探讨其在该任务中的实用性。形式概念分析(FCA)最近被提出作为主题建模的候选方法,但尚未有实际应用案例研究。在本研究中,我们比较LLM和FCA,以更好地了解它们在主题建模领域中的优缺点。FCA通过过去用于主题建模和可视化实验中使用的CREA流程进行评估,而GPT-5则用于LLM。在零样本设置下,GPT-5采用基于三个提示的策略:从文档批次生成主题、将批次结果合并为最终主题以及对主题进行标注。第一项实验重用了之前用于评估CREA的教学材料,而第二项实验分析了40篇信息系统研究论文,以比较提取的主题与底层子领域。

英文摘要:

Topic modeling is a research field finding increasing applications: historically from document retrieving, to sentiment analysis and text summarization. Large Language Models (LLM) are currently a major trend in text processing, but few works study their usefulness for this task. Formal Concept Analysis (FCA) has recently been presented as a candidate for topic modeling, but no real applied case study has been conducted. In this work, we compare LLM and FCA to better understand their strengths and weakneses in the topic modeling field. FCA is evaluated through the CREA pipeline used in past experiments on topic modeling and visualization, whereas GPT-5 is used for the LLM. A strategy based on three prompts is applied with GPT-5 in a zero-shot setup: topic generation from document batches, merging of batch results into final topics, and topic labeling. A first experiment reuses the teaching materials previously used to evaluate CREA, while a second experiment analyzes 40 research articles in information systems to compare the extracted topics with the underling subfields.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑