映射随机惩罚殖民地
Mapping the Stochastic Penal Colony
AI总结:
本文重新审视内容审核的惩罚机制,结合自动民族志和程序正义分析,探讨审核机构自我利益驱动下对违规用户不公正的惩罚行为。
摘要:
在峰值内容 moderation 看似告一段落之际,本文重新审视其惩罚性方面。但本文并未聚焦于被不公正审核的用户,而是聚焦于惩罚本身,探讨内容审核如何对发布违规内容的用户不公正对待,而执行审核的组织则以自我利益为导向。首先,本文重新构建福柯的惩罚系统模型,将惩罚殖民地重新定义为一种介于惩罚作为表演与惩罚作为纪律之间的象征性过渡实践,即随机惩罚殖民地。其次,本文发展了一种结合自动民族志收集经验和物品与程序正义分析的新型方法论。最后,本文将这一概念和方法论框架应用于三个案例研究:预马斯克推特的表演性审核、OpenAI对DALL-E 2的彻底控制性审核,以及Pinterest的隐蔽操纵性审核。尽管差异显著,这三个案例均体现出账户停用的普遍威胁,将用户驱逐至随机惩罚殖民地。
英文摘要:
With peak content moderation seemingly behind us, this paper revisits its punitive side. But instead of focusing on who is being (disproportionately) moderated, it focuses on the punishment itself and explores the question of how content moderation treats users posting violative content unjustly, while the organizations doing the moderation act in a self-serving manner. First, this paper reworks Foucault's model of the penal system for the algorithmic age, restoring the penal colony as a figuratively liminal practice between punishment as performance and punishment as discipline, i.e., the stochastic penal colony. Second, it develops a novel methodology that combines auto-ethnography for collecting experiences and artifacts with procedural justice for analyzing them. Third, it applies this conceptual and methodological framing to three case studies, one on pre-Musk Twitter's gallingly performative moderation, one on OpenAI's exhaustively controlling moderation for DALL-E 2, and one on Pinterest's underhandedly manipulative moderation. While substantially different, all three feature the pervasive threat of account suspension, which banishes users to the stochastic penal colony.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。