arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2602.00022cs.LG
收藏

对不透明系统的测量:多源三角测量与可解释机器学习

Measurement for Opaque Systems: Multi-source Triangulation with Interpretable Machine Learning

National Security Data and Policy Institute, University of Virginia(美国弗吉尼亚大学国家安全数据与政策研究所)

Margaret Foster

AI总结:

本文提出了一种用于不透明系统的测量框架,结合多源三角测量和可解释机器学习,以填补无法直接接触的测量空间。

摘要:

我们提出了一种用于难以直接接触情境的测量框架,该框架利用间接的数据轨迹、可解释的机器学习模型和理论指导的三角测量来填补无法接触的测量空间。许多具有高影响的科学和政策系统难以甚至不可能直接接触:感兴趣的动态是不可观测的,数据是间接且分散在多个来源中,且真实情况不存在或被隐藏。在这些情况下,可用数据往往不支持传统的分析策略,例如对单一权威数据流进行统计推断或对有标签的结果进行模型验证。为了解决这个问题,我们引入了一个通用的测量框架,用于数据制度中结构性缺失或对抗性数据的环境。我们提出将多源三角测量与可解释的机器学习模型相结合。而不是依赖于对不可观测、无法达到的理想数据的准确性,我们的框架寻求不同、部分信息模型之间的一致性。这使用户能够基于信号之间的一致性或与预期状态的偏离来得出有根据的结论。我们的框架提供了一个分析流程,专门针对缺乏足够数据进行传统统计或因果推断的定量描述。我们通过对一个秘密军事组织的组织增长和内部压力动态的实证分析来展示我们的方法,并明确揭示推断的限制,该分析利用了多个观测信号,这些信号单独提供不完整且有偏见的对潜在过程的看法。结果展示了三角化、可解释的机器学习如何恢复实质性有意义的变化。

英文摘要:

We propose a measurement framework for difficult-to-access contexts that uses indirect data traces, interpretable machine-learning models, and theory-guided triangulation to fill inaccessible measurement spaces. Many high-stakes systems of scientific and policy interest are difficult, if not impossible, to reach directly: dynamics of interest are unobservable, data are indirect and fragmented across sources, and ground truth is absent or concealed. In these settings, available data often do not support conventional strategies for analysis, such as statistical inference on a single authoritative data stream or model validation against labeled outcomes. To address this problem, we introduce a general framework for measurement in data regimes characterized by structurally missing or adversarial data. We propose combining multi-source triangulation with interpretable machine learning models. Rather than relying on accuracy against unobservable, unattainable ideal data, our framework seeks consistency across separate, partially informative models. This allows users to draw defensible conclusions about the state of the world based on cross-signal consistency or divergence from an expected state. Our framework provides an analytical workflow tailored to quantitative characterization in the absence of data sufficient for conventional statistical or causal inference. We demonstrate our approach and explicitly surface inferential limits through an empirical analysis of organizational growth and internal pressure dynamics in a clandestine militant organization, drawing on multiple observational signals that individually provide incomplete and biased views of the underlying process. The results show how triangulated, interpretable ML can recover substantively meaningful variation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑