arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2601.18566cs.SE
收藏

关于取消“ICSE论文”并采用“注册提案”和“结果报告”

On the Abolition of the "ICSE Paper" and the Adoption of the "Registered Proposal" and the "Results Report"

Univ. of Trento(特伦托大学);Vrije Univ. Amsterdam(阿姆斯特丹自由大学)

Fabio Massacci, Winnie Mbaka

AI总结:

本文提出取消现有的ICSE论文制度,改用注册提案和结果报告的两级系统,以解决新颖性恶性循环和可复制性危机问题。

摘要:

为了解决领域内的‘新颖性恶性循环’和‘可复制性危机’(这两者在调查中均有讨论),我们提出取消现有的‘ICSE论文’并用一种两级系统替代,同时演变现有的‘注册报告’概念。提出新想法、实验或分析的作者将提交其想法的‘注册提案’及所提议的实验方法以接受同行评审。次年,任何人都可以提交(较短的)‘结果报告’,基于前一年ICSE(或FSE或ISSTA或ASE等)的注册提案来呈现实证工作的实现。这两项工作都应成为主流会议的一级公民。我们主张这种颠覆(异端?)的想法得到支持,并基于未来软件工程预调查社区的回应。

英文摘要:

To address the 'novelty-vicious cycle' and the 'replicability crisis' of the field (both discussed in the survey) we propose abolishing the "ICSE paper" as we know it and replacing it with a two-tier system that also evolves the existing notion of 'Registered Report'. Authors proposing a new idea, experiment, or analysis would submit a "Registered Proposal" of their idea and the proposed experimental methodology to undergo peer review. The following year, anyone can submit (shorter) "Results Reports" on the realization of the empirical work based on the registered proposals of the previous ICSE (or FSE or ISSTA or ASE etc.). Both works should be first class citizens of the mainstream events. We argue that such a disruptive (heretical?) idea is supported and based on the responses of the community of the Future of Software Engineering pre-survey

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑