arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2601.17846cs.HC
收藏

AI个性化悖论:个性化AI在阅读中增加浅层参与,而在写作中削弱自主性和归属感

AI Personalization Paradox: Personalized AI Increases Superficial Engagement in Reading while Undermines Autonomy and Ownership in Writing

National University of Singapore(新加坡国立大学);Tongji University(同济大学)

Peinuan Qin, Chi-Lan Yang, Nattapat Boonprakong, Jingzhu Chen, Yugin Tan, Yi-Chieh Lee

AI总结:

本研究发现,个性化AI在阅读中提升参与度,但在写作中削弱自主性和归属感,强调了个性化设计的风险与重要性。

摘要:

AI辅助写作在提升写作者收益的同时,引发了关于自主性和归属感的担忧。个性化被提出作为有效的解决方案,但同时也可能使写作者依赖AI并改变其行为。为了更好地设计个性化功能,现有研究仅依赖写作阶段内的互动和信息;然而,很少有研究探讨阅读行为如何影响个性化写作。本研究探讨了在AI辅助写作中整合阅读高亮标记以实现个性化的效果。一项46名参与者参与的组间研究发现,个性化条件促使参与者产生更多的高亮标记。然而,高亮标记意外地从一种意义建构策略转变为一种“喂养AI”的工具性行为,导致对AI的显著依赖以及写作者自主性、归属感和自我评价的下降。这些发现表明AI辅助写作中的个性化风险,强调了个性化策略的重要性,并提供了设计启示。

英文摘要:

AI-assisted writing raises concerns about autonomy and ownership when benefiting writers. Personalization has been proposed as an effective solution while also risking writers' reliance on AI and behavior shifting. For better personalization design, existing studies rely on interaction and information solely within the writing phase; however, few studies have examined how reading behaviors can inform personalized writing. This study investigates the effects of integrating reading highlights for personalization on AI-assisted writing. A between-subjects study with 46 participants revealed that the personalization condition encouraged participants to produce more highlights. However, highlighting unexpectedly shifted from a sense-making strategy to an instrumental act of "feeding the AI," leading to significant reliance on AI and declines in writers' sense of autonomy, ownership, and self-credit. These findings indicate personalization risks in AI-assisted writing, emphasize the importance of personalization strategies, and provide design implications.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑